My employer wants to recover salary it says was paid to me by mistake years ago. Can it?
It depends on the facts. The Supreme Court has held that recovery of an excess payment made by the employer's mistake is impermissible from Group C and Group D employees, from retired employees or employees due to retire within one year of the recovery order, where the excess was paid for more than five years before the recovery order, and where an employee was made to work on a higher post and paid for it.
In any other case, the question is whether recovery would be so harsh or arbitrary that it outweighs the employer's right to recover. How the mistake arose, and your service status, matter. Ask for the recovery order and the calculation in writing, reply to any show cause notice, and challenge the order before the Central Administrative Tribunal or the High Court, as the case may be.
What to do, in order
- Ask for the recovery order and the calculation of the alleged excess in writing.
- Note your group or class of service, your date of retirement and the period over which the excess was paid.
- Reply to any show cause notice, stating the facts that bring you within the protected situations.
- Challenge the order before the Central Administrative Tribunal or the High Court, as the case may be, if recovery goes ahead.
The law
Law: Article 14, Constitution of India; State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer), (2015) 4 SCC 334. Read more: Service matters.
Last reviewed: 15/11/2026
Practice area: Tax, Customs and Specialised
This page is an educational summary of the law as at 15/11/2026. It is not legal advice.
← Know the Law