Criminal Contempt: Scandalising, Interference, Consent and the Defences
Criminal contempt protects the administration of justice itself, not the personal dignity of judges. Because it touches free speech and personal liberty, the Act limits who can set it in motion and lists the defences.
In brief
- Definition. A publication or act that scandalises or lowers the authority of a court, interferes with a judicial proceeding, or obstructs the administration of justice (Section 2(c)).
- Who can start it. The court on its own motion, the Advocate General, or any other person with the Advocate General's written consent; in the Supreme Court, the Attorney General or Solicitor General; in Delhi, the specified Law Officer (Section 15).
- Bench. At least two judges (Section 18).
- Defences. Innocent publication, fair and accurate reports, fair comment on a decided case, good-faith complaints, and truth in the public interest (Sections 3 to 7 and 13(b)).
- Supreme Court. Articles 129 and 142(2); its power also protects the subordinate courts.
- Appeal. Against a punishment, to the Supreme Court within 60 days (Section 19).
Terms you will hear
- Criminal contempt
- Conduct or publication that scandalises or lowers the authority of a court, interferes with a judicial proceeding, or obstructs the administration of justice (Section 2(c)).
- Scandalising the court
- An attack on a court or judge tending to lower the court's authority, as distinct from criticism of a judgment.
- Contempt in the face of the court
- Contempt in the presence or hearing of the court, dealt with summarily under Section 14.
- Law Officer
- For the High Court of Delhi, the officer specified by the Central Government under Section 15, whose written consent a private person needs.
- Reference
- A subordinate court's report to the High Court of a contempt committed against it.
- Suo motu
- Of the court's own motion.
- Justification by truth
- The Section 13(b) defence, available where the court is satisfied it is in the public interest and the request is bona fide.
In detail
This article is in 6 parts:
Criminal contempt: scandalising and interference
Section 2(c) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 defines criminal contempt as the publication, by words spoken or written, by signs, by visible representations or otherwise, of any matter, or the doing of any other act whatsoever, which:
- scandalises or tends to scandalise, or lowers or tends to lower, the authority of any court;
- prejudices, or interferes or tends to interfere with, the due course of any judicial proceeding; or
- interferes or tends to interfere with, or obstructs or tends to obstruct, the administration of justice in any other manner.
The Supreme Court has explained that the power exists not to protect the dignity of the court against insult, but to protect the public's right that the administration of justice is not perverted, prejudiced, obstructed or interfered with, and that deliberate interference with judicial duties by attacking presiding officers, in court or outside it, is criminal contempt (Delhi Judicial Service Association v. State of Gujarat, (1991) 4 SCC 406).
The three kinds in practice
- Scandalising: unfounded allegations of corruption or bias against a judge, published to the public, or abuse of the court as an institution. Criticism of a judgment is different, and Section 5 protects fair comment on a case heard and finally decided.
- Interference with a pending proceeding: publications prejudging a case, or pressure on a witness or party. Under the Explanation to Section 3 a civil case is pending from the filing of the plaint, a criminal case from the charge-sheet or the issue of summons or warrant, and either until the appeal or revision is decided or the time for it expires.
- Obstruction: disruption of proceedings, threats to judicial officers, or obstruction of court process.
Contempt in the face of the court
Under Section 14 the Supreme Court or a High Court may detain a person for contempt committed in its presence or hearing and, the same day or as early as possible, inform the person of the charge in writing, hear the defence and decide. On request, and where practicable, the matter goes to the Chief Justice for trial by another judge. In Delhi, Rule 4 of the Contempt of Courts (Delhi High Court) Rules, 2025 provides for the charge in Form I, for listing a transferred matter before a Division Bench, and that the judge concerned need not appear as a witness.
Procedure and punishment
- Criminal contempt under Section 15 is heard by a Bench of at least two judges (Section 18); in Delhi, before a Division Bench as per roster (Rule 9(2)).
- Notice is served personally with copies of the motion and affidavits or the reference, and the person charged may file an affidavit in defence (Section 17). In Delhi a plea of guilt is recorded; otherwise the court decides on affidavits or further evidence and hears the contemnor on sentence (Rules 12 and 13).
- The punishment is the same as for civil contempt: up to six months' simple imprisonment, a fine of up to Rs. 2,000, or both (Section 12(1)), with no sentence unless the contempt substantially interferes, or tends to interfere, with the due course of justice (Section 13(a)).
Consent of the Attorney General or Advocate General (Section 15)
Criminal contempt other than contempt in the face of the court is set in motion only as Section 15(1) allows. The Supreme Court or a High Court may act on its own motion; on a motion by the Advocate General; on a motion by any other person with the Advocate General's written consent; or, for the High Court for the Union territory of Delhi, on a motion by the Law Officer the Central Government specifies by notification, or by any other person with that Law Officer's written consent (Section 15(1)(c)). For the Supreme Court, "Advocate General" means the Attorney General or the Solicitor General, and for a High Court, the Advocate General of the State (Explanation). The requirement filters motions by private persons; it does not limit the court's power to act on its own motion.
In the High Court of Delhi
The 2025 Rules define the Law Officer by reference to the Central Government's notification (Rule 3(f)) and allow cognizance on the Law Officer's motion or recommendation, on the motion of any other person with the Law Officer's prior written consent, on a district court's reference, on information from the Registrar General or any other person, or suo motu (Rule 5(2)). Information from a person not referred to in Section 15 goes not to the judicial side but to the Chief Justice in chambers, who may take cognizance or consult other judges (Rules 5(3) and 9(3)).
In Sujata Kohli v. Rajiv Khosla, CONT.CAS.(CRL) 1/2022, High Court of Delhi, decided 28/02/2024, the Standing Counsel (Criminal) produced a Central Government notification of 18/05/1973 (S.O. 1528), issued under Section 15(2), specifying the Standing Counsel (Criminal) to the Delhi Administration as the Law Officer for the Union territory of Delhi, and the High Court proceeded on the basis that a complainant who had obtained written consent under Section 15 could file the petition. Notice to the Government in Delhi criminal contempt matters goes to the Standing Counsel (Criminal), Government of NCT of Delhi, in Form III of the 2025 Rules.
In the Supreme Court
Under Rule 3 of the Rules to Regulate Proceedings for Contempt of the Supreme Court, 1975, the Court acts suo motu, on a petition by the Attorney General or the Solicitor General, or on a petition by any person, which for criminal contempt needs the written consent of the Attorney General or the Solicitor General. The petition states the parties, the contempt and the material facts with dates, and any earlier petition, with an affidavit; no court fee is payable (Rule 4). At a preliminary hearing the Court dismisses it or issues notice (Rule 5).
Applying for consent
- Send the Law Officer the material said to be contempt, with its date, the court and proceeding affected, and why it falls within Section 2(c).
- The one-year limit in Section 20 runs while consent is sought; the limitation page for the Act explains when proceedings are treated as initiated.
- If consent is refused, the material can still be placed before the court as information, which in Delhi goes to the Chief Justice under Rule 9(3).
Contempt of subordinate courts and references
Section 10 gives every High Court the same jurisdiction in respect of contempt of the courts subordinate to it as for contempt of itself. Its proviso excludes contempt that is an offence punishable under the Indian Penal Code, which the Act still names (the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 replaced the Penal Code from 01/07/2024); such conduct goes to the criminal courts. Under Section 11 the High Court may try such contempt whether committed, or the person is, within or outside its territorial limits.
How it reaches the High Court
Under Section 15(2) the High Court may act on a reference by the subordinate court, or on a motion by the Advocate General or, in a Union territory, the specified Law Officer; the reference or motion must specify the contempt (Section 15(3)).
References from district courts in Delhi
- "District court" covers all courts and tribunals under the administrative control of the High Court (Rule 3(i)).
- A reference gives the parties and the nature and material facts of the contempt with dates, with attested copies of the relevant documents (Rule 8(1) and (2)).
- A reference by a court other than the Principal District and Sessions Judge goes through that judge to the Registrar General, and is registered as a petition (Rule 8(3) and (4)).
- A district court may also refer civil contempt of itself (Rule 5(1)(c)).
Complaints about a subordinate judge
Section 6 protects a statement made in good faith about the presiding officer of a subordinate court to any other subordinate court, or to the High Court, to which it is subordinate. A grievance about a judicial officer should be raised through those channels, in measured terms.
The Supreme Court's concurrent power
The Supreme Court has held that it has a right and a duty to protect the courts whose orders are amenable to its correction from contempt, concurrently with the High Courts (Delhi Judicial Service Association v. State of Gujarat, (1991) 4 SCC 406).
Truth and fair comment (Section 13, Section 5)
The Act lists conduct that is not contempt. Section 8 preserves any other defence valid before the Act, and Section 9 provides that the Act does not make punishable anything that would not be punishable as contempt apart from it.
Fair comment on a decided case (Section 5)
A person is not guilty of contempt for publishing any fair comment on the merits of any case which has been heard and finally decided. The protection covers comment on the reasoning and result of a decision; it does not extend to imputing motives to the judge, and it does not cover a case still pending.
Justification by truth (Section 13(b))
Section 13, as substituted by the Contempt of Courts (Amendment) Act, 2006 with effect from 17/03/2006, allows the court to permit justification by truth as a valid defence if it is satisfied that it is in the public interest and the request for invoking the defence is bona fide. The defence is not automatic; the person must show both truth and public interest; and a bona fide request in practice means having the material when the statement was made, and setting it out on affidavit.
The other statutory protections
- Innocent publication (Section 3): no contempt where the publisher had no reasonable grounds to believe the proceeding was pending, and none at all by such publication where no proceeding is pending; distributors are protected on similar terms.
- Fair and accurate reports (Section 4) of a judicial proceeding, subject to Section 7.
- Chambers and in camera (Section 7): reports are protected unless publication breaches an enactment, the court has expressly prohibited it, the court sat privately for reasons of public order or State security, or a secret process or invention is in issue.
- Good-faith complaints about a subordinate judge (Section 6).
Apology
The court may discharge the accused or remit the punishment on an apology made to its satisfaction, and a bona fide apology is not to be rejected merely because it is qualified or conditional (Section 12(1)). Apologies offered only on paper to escape punishment have been refused (L.D. Jaikwal v. State of U.P., (1984) 3 SCC 405).
The Supreme Court's contempt jurisdiction (Article 129)
Article 129 of the Constitution makes the Supreme Court a court of record with all the powers of such a court, including the power to punish for contempt of itself. Article 142(2) adds that, subject to any law made by Parliament, the Court may make any order for the investigation or punishment of any contempt of itself. Article 215 confers the corresponding power on every High Court.
The 1971 Act and the Supreme Court
In Supreme Court Bar Association v. Union of India, (1998) 4 SCC 409 the Supreme Court held that the Act does not deal with its powers to punish contempt of itself or of the courts subordinate to it, which Articles 142(2) and 129 alone govern; an Act of Parliament cannot take away the inherent jurisdiction of a court of record, though it may guide the punishment. The Court also held that it cannot, while punishing an advocate for contempt, suspend the advocate's licence; professional misconduct is for the Bar Council under the Advocates Act, 1961.
Procedure in the Supreme Court
- Contempt in the view, presence or hearing of the Court may be punished forthwith or on a date appointed (Rule 2 of the 1975 Rules).
- The person charged must, unless otherwise ordered, appear in person and remain present until disposal (Rule 6(1)), and may reply on affidavit (Rule 7).
- The Court may ask the Attorney General or Solicitor General to assist (Rule 10), order cross-examination on affidavits (Rule 12), and award costs recoverable as a decree (Rule 14).
The Court's power under Article 129 also protects the subordinate courts, concurrently with the High Courts (Delhi Judicial Service Association v. State of Gujarat, (1991) 4 SCC 406). There is no appeal from an order of the Supreme Court; the remedies are review and, in narrow cases, a curative petition, which the SLP explainer describes.
Appeals
Section 19(1) gives an appeal as of right from any order or decision of the High Court in the exercise of its jurisdiction to punish for contempt: from a single judge to a Bench of at least two judges, and from a Bench to the Supreme Court. Because Section 18 requires criminal contempt under Section 15 to be heard by a Bench of at least two judges, an appeal against a punishment for criminal contempt ordinarily lies to the Supreme Court, within 60 days from the date of the order (Section 19(4)(b)). A punishment by a single judge for contempt in the face of the court under Section 14 is appealed to a Bench of the High Court within 30 days (Section 19(4)(a)).
What can be appealed
The appeal under Section 19 lies only against an order imposing punishment. An order declining to initiate, dropping proceedings, or acquitting the person charged is not appealable under Section 19, though in special circumstances it may be challenged under Article 136 (Midnapore Peoples' Coop. Bank Ltd. v. Chunilal Nanda, (2006) 5 SCC 399).
Pending the appeal
The appellate court may suspend the punishment, release the appellant on bail, and hear the appeal though the contempt has not been purged (Section 19(2)); the High Court may do the same where an appeal is intended (Section 19(3)). In Delhi, no court fee is payable on a contemnor's memorandum of appeal to a Bench of the High Court (Rule 14 of the 2025 Rules).
Questions people ask
What is criminal contempt of court?
Under Section 2(c) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, criminal contempt is the publication of any matter, or the doing of any act, which scandalises or lowers the authority of a court, prejudices or interferes with the due course of a judicial proceeding, or obstructs the administration of justice in any other manner. It protects the public's interest in the administration of justice rather than the personal dignity of a judge. It is heard by a Bench of at least two judges, and the punishment is capped at six months' simple imprisonment, a fine of Rs. 2,000, or both.
Is criticising a judgment contempt of court?
Fair criticism of a judgment is not contempt. Section 5 of the Act protects fair comment on the merits of a case that has been heard and finally decided: its reasoning, its result and its effects. What can amount to contempt is an attack on the judge rather than the judgment, such as unfounded allegations of corruption or bias, or comment that prejudges a case still pending and tends to interfere with it. The line depends on the words used, the occasion and whether the case is pending, so anything beyond comment on the merits should be considered carefully before it is published.
Can I file a criminal contempt case against someone myself?
Not on your own. Under Section 15(1) a private person can move the Supreme Court or a High Court for criminal contempt only with the written consent of the Advocate General; for the Supreme Court that means the Attorney General or the Solicitor General, and for the High Court of Delhi the Law Officer specified by the Central Government. Without consent, the material can be placed before the court as information. In Delhi such information goes to the Chief Justice in chambers, who may take cognizance or consult other judges.
Whose consent is needed for criminal contempt in the Delhi High Court?
Section 15(1)(c) requires the consent of the Law Officer the Central Government specifies by notification for the High Court of Delhi. A notification of 18/05/1973 (S.O. 1528), produced before the High Court in a 2024 case, specifies the Standing Counsel (Criminal) to the Delhi Administration as the Law Officer for Section 15(2). The Contempt of Courts (Delhi High Court) Rules, 2025 define the Law Officer by reference to the Central Government's notification and allow cognizance on the motion of any person with the Law Officer's prior written consent.
How does contempt of a district court reach the High Court?
Under Section 15(2), on a reference by the subordinate court itself, or on a motion by the Advocate General or, in a Union territory, the specified Law Officer. In Delhi, a reference by a court other than the Principal District and Sessions Judge is forwarded through the Principal District and Sessions Judge to the Registrar General, with the particulars and attested documents, and is registered as a petition. The High Court cannot take cognizance under Section 10 where the conduct is itself an offence under the penal law; that is dealt with under the criminal law.
Is truth a defence to criminal contempt?
It can be. Section 13(b), in force since 17/03/2006, allows the court to permit justification by truth as a valid defence if it is satisfied that it is in the public interest and that the request to invoke the defence is bona fide. The defence is not automatic: the person must show both that the statement is true and that publishing it served the public interest, and must set out the material on affidavit. A statement made without material in hand, in the hope of proving it later, is unlikely to meet the test.
What is the punishment for criminal contempt?
Section 12(1) allows simple imprisonment for up to six months, a fine of up to Rs. 2,000, or both, and Section 12(2) bars any greater sentence for contempt of the court itself or of a subordinate court. Section 13(a) bars any sentence unless the contempt substantially interferes, or tends substantially to interfere, with the due course of justice. The court may discharge the person or remit the punishment on an apology made to its satisfaction. The Supreme Court has held that its own power under Article 129 is not taken away by the Act, but that it cannot suspend an advocate's licence as a punishment for contempt.
Does the Supreme Court follow the Contempt of Courts Act?
The Supreme Court's power comes from Articles 129 and 142(2) of the Constitution. It has held that the 1971 Act does not deal with its power to punish contempt of itself or of the courts subordinate to it, and that an Act of Parliament cannot take away the inherent jurisdiction of a court of record, though the Act serves as a guide to punishment. Its procedure is governed by the Rules to Regulate Proceedings for Contempt of the Supreme Court, 1975, under which a private petition for criminal contempt needs the written consent of the Attorney General or the Solicitor General.
Can I appeal a conviction for criminal contempt?
Yes. Section 19 gives an appeal as of right against an order punishing for contempt. Criminal contempt is heard by a Bench of at least two judges, so the appeal ordinarily lies to the Supreme Court and must be filed within 60 days from the date of the order. Pending the appeal, the punishment can be suspended and the appellant released on bail, and the appeal can be heard even though the contempt has not been purged. An order acquitting the person charged is not appealable under Section 19.
Is there a time limit for criminal contempt proceedings?
Yes. Section 20 bars any court from initiating proceedings for contempt, on its own motion or otherwise, after one year from the date on which the contempt is alleged to have been committed, and the Delhi rules repeat the bar. Where a private person must first obtain the Law Officer's consent, the consent application should be made promptly, because the year keeps running. The counting rules are on the site's limitation page for the Contempt of Courts Act.
These answers are educational summaries; they are not legal advice on any individual matter.
A serious question deserves a read brief.
Conferences are by appointment at G-46, Basement, Greater Kailash III, New Delhi. The principal reads the correspondence.
This page gives general information about the work of Lokesh Bhardwaj Law Offices, as permitted under the Bar Council of India Rules. It is not legal advice, and it does not create an advocate-client relationship. LBLO acts in a matter only on an engagement agreed in writing.
Law stated as at 16/11/2026.
← All Practice Areas