Interconnection, Broadcasting, IT Act and Airport Tariff Appeals: The Wider Jurisdiction of the TDSAT
The TDSAT decides more than licence disputes. It hears disputes between service providers, including broadcasters and cable operators, appeals under the Information Technology Act, 2000 and appeals on airport tariffs under the Airports Economic Regulatory Authority of India Act, 2008. Each stream has its own statute, time limit and route of appeal.
In brief
- Interconnection and disputes between operators. TRAI fixes the terms of interconnection and the sharing of revenue between service providers by regulation. A dispute between two or more service providers goes to the TDSAT under Section 14(a)(ii) of the TRAI Act, 1997.
- Broadcasting and cable. Broadcasters, distribution platform operators (cable multi-system operators, DTH, HITS and IPTV operators) and local cable operators are service providers under the TRAI Act, and their commercial disputes go to the TDSAT. TRAI may direct compliance with its regulations, but it cannot decide the parties' rights (Supreme Court, 24/07/2026).
- IT Act appeals. Orders of an Adjudicating Officer or the Controller of Certifying Authorities under the Information Technology Act, 2000 are appealed to the TDSAT within 45 days (Section 57). A further appeal lies to the High Court, not the Supreme Court, within 60 days (Section 62).
- Airport tariffs. Tariff and other orders of the Airports Economic Regulatory Authority of India (AERA) are appealed to the TDSAT within 30 days (Section 18, AERA Act). A further appeal lies to the Supreme Court within 90 days (Section 31).
- Time limits run from receipt of the order, and each statute allows a late appeal only on sufficient cause. Record the date of receipt the day the order arrives.
Terms you will hear
- Service provider
- Under the TRAI Act, the Government as a service provider and any licensee. Broadcasting and cable distribution are regulated as telecommunication services, so their operators are service providers for the Tribunal's jurisdiction.
- Interconnection
- The commercial and technical arrangement by which one network connects to another so that their users can reach each other, or by which a broadcaster's channels reach a distributor's subscribers.
- Distribution platform operator (DPO)
- A multi-system operator, DTH operator, HITS operator or IPTV operator that distributes television channels to subscribers, directly or through local cable operators.
- Multi-system operator (MSO) and local cable operator (LCO)
- The MSO receives channels from broadcasters and distributes them; the LCO takes the signal from the MSO and serves subscribers in its area.
- Regulation and direction
- TRAI's regulations under Section 36 of the TRAI Act are subordinate legislation. A direction under Section 13 requires a service provider to comply with them, and wilful disobedience is punishable by a magistrate.
- Adjudicating Officer (IT Act)
- An officer of at least Director rank who decides contraventions and compensation claims under the Information Technology Act, 2000 up to Rs. 5 crore (Section 46).
- Major airport
- An airport with annual passenger throughput above three and a half million, or an airport or group of airports the Central Government notifies (Section 2(i), AERA Act).
- Aeronautical services
- The services at a major airport, such as landing, parking and passenger facilities, for which AERA determines tariffs under Section 13 of the AERA Act.
In detail
Interconnection and inter-operator disputes
Where the rules come from
Section 11(1)(b) of the TRAI Act, 1997 gives TRAI the functions of fixing the terms and conditions of interconnectivity between service providers, ensuring effective interconnection between them, regulating arrangements among them for sharing revenue, and laying down standards of quality of service. TRAI exercises these functions mainly by regulations under Section 36. The Supreme Court has described that regulation-making power as wide and pervasive, subject only to the Act and the rules made under it (Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited v. Telecom Regulatory Authority of India, (2014) 3 SCC 222, as relied on by the Supreme Court in 2026). Interconnection regulations bind every service provider, and the terms of an interconnection agreement are read with them.
What the disputes are about
Disputes between service providers include refusal or delay in providing points of interconnection, disconnection, billing and settlement of interconnection usage and carriage charges, set-off of dues between operators, roaming and infrastructure-sharing terms, and the effect of a TRAI regulation on an existing agreement. Section 14(a)(ii) gives the TDSAT jurisdiction over any dispute between two or more service providers, and Section 15 bars civil courts from those matters.
TRAI's role and the Tribunal's
In Telecom Regulatory Authority of India v. Polimer Cable Network, 2026 INSC 742, decided on 24/07/2026, the Supreme Court drew the line between the regulator and the Tribunal. TRAI may issue directions under Section 13, read with Section 11(1)(b), to secure compliance with a regulation or licence condition, and may record a prima facie finding of non-compliance for that limited purpose. Where a direction is wilfully disobeyed, TRAI may file a complaint under Section 34, and the penalty under Section 29 is decided by a court not below a Chief Metropolitan Magistrate or Chief Judicial Magistrate. TRAI cannot finally decide the parties' rights inter se, award damages, quantify arrears, entertain counter-claims or mould relief. Where the true substance of the grievance is a dispute between two service providers, rather than a breach of a regulation, it lies before the TDSAT under Sections 14 and 14A.
For a service provider this produces two routes. A direction of TRAI is challenged by appeal to the TDSAT within 30 days of receiving it, with a later appeal allowed on sufficient cause (Section 14A(2) and (3)). A claim against another operator for money, restoration or compliance with an agreement is brought as a petition under Section 14(a)(ii). Choosing the wrong one, or treating a regulatory direction as a commercial dispute, is a common and avoidable error.
Interim relief
Interconnection disputes are often urgent, because a disconnection takes users or channels off a network immediately. The petition is filed with an application for interim relief, and the Tribunal can direct restoration or status quo on terms, such as payment of an admitted amount or a deposit, while the dispute is heard.
Broadcasting and cable disputes
How broadcasting came under the TRAI Act
The TRAI Act defines telecommunication service to exclude broadcasting, but its proviso allows the Central Government to notify other services, including broadcasting, as telecommunication services. Broadcasting and cable services are regulated by TRAI on that basis, and broadcasters, distribution platform operators and local cable operators are service providers for the Tribunal's jurisdiction. Cable operators are registered under the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995.
The regulatory framework
The commercial relationship between broadcasters and distributors of channels through addressable systems is governed principally by the Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable) Services Interconnection (Addressable Systems) Regulations, 2017 of 03/03/2017, as amended, read with TRAI's tariff order and quality of service regulations for addressable systems, and the regulations on registering interconnection agreements. These regulate, among other things, the terms on which a broadcaster must provide signals, the reference interconnection offer, carriage and placement fees, the information a distributor must share, audits of subscriber management and conditional access systems, and the notice required before signals are disconnected. TRAI continues to amend the framework; a draft seventh amendment to the 2017 interconnection regulations was issued in 2025, so the version in force on the relevant date must be used.
Common disputes
- a broadcaster's demand for subscription fees based on audited subscriber numbers, and disputes over the audit;
- disconnection of signals for non-payment, and whether the notice the regulations require was given;
- carriage fees and placement of channels on a distributor's platform or electronic programme guide;
- disputes between an MSO and its LCOs over revenue share, signal supply and the terms of their agreement;
- refusal to provide channels on the reference interconnection offer.
In the Polimer case itself, the regulator had acted on complaints by local cable operators that their MSO abruptly disconnected signals. The Supreme Court held that TRAI could direct the MSO to comply with the notice requirement in the interconnection regulations, but the commercial dispute between the MSO and the LCOs over their subscription arrangement remained one for the TDSAT.
What is outside
An individual subscriber's complaint about a DTH or cable service goes to the consumer commission or the provider's grievance machinery, not to the Tribunal. A group of consumers may bring a dispute with a service provider before the TDSAT. Questions of programme content are governed separately and are not the subject of this page.
IT Act appeals before the TDSAT
Who decides at first instance
Under Section 46 of the Information Technology Act, 2000, the Central Government appoints Adjudicating Officers, not below the rank of Director, to decide whether a person has contravened the Act or the rules, directions or orders under it, and to award compensation or impose penalty. Since the 2009 amendments, the Adjudicating Officer decides claims for injury or damage up to Rs. 5 crore; a claim above that goes to the competent court (Section 46(1A)). Section 47 lists the factors for quantifying compensation: the unfair gain, the loss caused and the repetitive nature of the default. The Controller of Certifying Authorities also makes orders that can be appealed.
These proceedings typically concern unauthorised access to a computer system, data theft or damage under Section 43, and, until it is omitted, failure by a body corporate to maintain reasonable security practices for sensitive personal data under Section 43A. The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 omits Section 43A, and under the DPDP commencement notification of 13/11/2025 that change takes effect on 13/05/2027.
The appeal to the TDSAT
Since the Finance Act, 2017 the TDSAT is the Appellate Tribunal under the IT Act; the Cyber Appellate Tribunal no longer exists (Section 48(1)). An appeal against an order of the Controller or an Adjudicating Officer is filed within 45 days from the date on which the appellant receives a copy of the order, and the Tribunal may admit a later appeal on sufficient cause (Section 57(3)). No appeal lies against an order made with the consent of the parties (Section 57(2)). Civil courts cannot entertain matters the Adjudicating Officer or the Tribunal is empowered to decide (Section 61).
The further appeal goes to the High Court
This is where IT Act matters differ from telecom and airport matters. A person aggrieved by the Tribunal's decision under the IT Act appeals to the High Court, not the Supreme Court, within 60 days of communication of the decision, on any question of fact or law arising out of the order, and the High Court may allow a further 60 days on sufficient cause (Section 62). A party who files in the Supreme Court under Section 18 of the TRAI Act, by analogy with telecom matters, files in the wrong court.
Data protection appeals from 2027
The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 also uses the TDSAT as its Appellate Tribunal. A person aggrieved by an order or direction of the Data Protection Board may appeal within 60 days of receiving it, with a later appeal allowed on sufficient cause, and the Tribunal is to endeavour to dispose of the appeal within six months (Section 29). Under the commencement notification of 13/11/2025, Section 29 comes into force on 13/05/2027, together with the Act's substantive duties.
Airport tariff appeals under the AERA Act
What AERA regulates
The Airports Economic Regulatory Authority of India Act, 2008 created AERA to regulate tariffs at major airports. A major airport is one with annual passenger throughput above three and a half million, or any airport or group of airports the Central Government notifies (Section 2(i)). Under Section 13(1), AERA determines the tariff for aeronautical services, taking into account factors that include capital expenditure, quality of service, cost of improving efficiency, the economic viability of the airport, revenue from services other than aeronautical services, and any concession offered by the Central Government in an agreement or memorandum of understanding. AERA also determines development fees and the passenger service fee, and monitors performance standards.
Tariff orders affect airport operators, airlines, cargo and ground handling service providers and passengers, and the questions are usually about the regulatory building blocks: the regulatory asset base, the return allowed, the treatment of non-aeronautical revenue, and the effect of the concession agreement on what AERA may decide.
The appeal and the dispute jurisdiction
Since the Finance Act, 2017, the TDSAT exercises the appellate and dispute jurisdiction under the AERA Act (Section 17). It decides disputes between service providers and between a service provider and a group of consumers, and hears appeals against any direction, decision or order of AERA. Matters within the jurisdiction of the Competition Commission of India, individual consumer complaints and certain eviction appeals under the Airports Authority of India Act are excluded.
An appeal against an order of AERA is filed within 30 days from the date on which the appellant receives a copy, and the Tribunal may admit a later appeal on sufficient cause; it is to endeavour to dispose of the appeal within 90 days (Section 18). Civil courts are barred (Section 28), and the Tribunal's orders are executable as decrees (Section 32).
Appeal to the Supreme Court
An appeal lies from the Tribunal to the Supreme Court within 90 days, against an order that is not interlocutory, on the grounds in Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (Section 31). In Airports Economic Regulatory Authority of India v. Delhi International Airport Ltd., 2024 INSC 791, decided on 18/10/2024, the Supreme Court held that AERA's own appeals against orders of the TDSAT under Section 31 are maintainable, so a regulator whose tariff order is set aside can take the matter further.
Preparing an AERA appeal
The record before AERA is the record on appeal. The consultation paper, the stakeholder submissions, the authority's analysis and the tariff order are read together, and the appeal identifies where the order departs from Section 13, the concession agreement or the authority's own guidelines, and what the financial effect is. Because tariffs apply for defined periods, delay can make relief harder to give, and an application for interim directions may be needed.
Questions people ask
Can TRAI decide a dispute between two telecom operators?
No. TRAI regulates; the TDSAT adjudicates. In its judgment of 24/07/2026 in TRAI v. Polimer Cable Network, the Supreme Court held that TRAI may direct a service provider to comply with a regulation, record a prima facie finding of non-compliance for that purpose, and file a complaint before a magistrate if a direction is wilfully disobeyed. It cannot finally decide the parties' rights, award damages, quantify arrears or entertain counter-claims. A dispute between two or more service providers is brought before the TDSAT under Section 14(a)(ii) of the TRAI Act, 1997.
How do I challenge a TRAI direction or regulation applied to my company?
A direction, decision or order of TRAI is challenged by appeal to the TDSAT within 30 days from the date the appellant receives a copy (Section 14A(2) and (3) of the TRAI Act). The Tribunal may admit a later appeal if there was sufficient cause. The appeal should explain why the direction goes beyond the regulation or Section 11(1)(b), or why the facts do not support it. A regulation made under Section 36 is subordinate legislation laid before Parliament, so a challenge to the regulation itself raises different questions from a challenge to a direction issued under it.
Can an MSO disconnect a local cable operator's signals without notice?
Not without following the interconnection regulations. TRAI's regulations require prior notice before signals are disconnected, with reasons, and steps to inform subscribers. In the Polimer case the Supreme Court upheld TRAI's power to direct an MSO to comply with the notice requirement after LCOs complained of abrupt disconnection. The underlying commercial dispute, such as arrears of subscription or revenue share, is decided by the TDSAT, which can order restoration of signals and payment of dues together. Check the regulations in force on the date, because TRAI amends them from time to time.
Can a DTH or cable subscriber file a case in the TDSAT?
Not individually. The proviso to Section 14 of the TRAI Act excludes complaints of an individual consumer that a consumer forum can decide. An individual subscriber with a billing or service complaint uses the provider's grievance machinery or files a complaint before the consumer commission under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. A dispute between a service provider and a group of consumers is within the Tribunal's jurisdiction, so a body representing many subscribers with a common grievance may approach it.
What is the time limit for an appeal under the IT Act?
Forty-five days from the date on which the appellant receives a copy of the order of the Adjudicating Officer or the Controller, under Section 57(3) of the Information Technology Act, 2000. The TDSAT, which is now the Appellate Tribunal under that Act, may admit a later appeal if there was sufficient cause. No appeal lies against an order made with the consent of the parties. Keep the envelope, e-mail or portal record that shows when the order was received, because the 45 days are counted from receipt.
Where does an appeal from the TDSAT go in an IT Act case?
To the High Court, not the Supreme Court. Section 62 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 provides an appeal against any decision or order of the Appellate Tribunal to the High Court within 60 days from the date of communication of the decision, on any question of fact or law arising out of it. The High Court may allow it to be filed within a further 60 days if there was sufficient cause. This differs from telecom and airport matters, where the appeal from the TDSAT lies to the Supreme Court.
Who decides a claim for compensation for data theft under the IT Act?
An Adjudicating Officer appointed under Section 46 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 decides claims for injury or damage up to Rs. 5 crore. A claim above Rs. 5 crore goes to the competent court. The officer must give the person accused a reasonable opportunity to be heard and has some powers of a civil court. In quantifying compensation the officer considers the unfair advantage gained, the loss caused and whether the default was repeated (Section 47). The order can be appealed to the TDSAT within 45 days.
Will DPDP Act appeals go to the TDSAT?
Yes. Section 29 of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 provides an appeal to the TDSAT against an order or direction of the Data Protection Board within 60 days of receiving it, with a later appeal allowed on sufficient cause, and asks the Tribunal to try to decide it within six months. Under the commencement notification of 13/11/2025, Section 29 comes into force on 13/05/2027, together with the Act's main duties on data fiduciaries. On the same date the Act's omission of Section 43A of the IT Act takes effect.
Which airports does AERA regulate?
Major airports. Under Section 2(i) of the Airports Economic Regulatory Authority of India Act, 2008, a major airport is one with annual passenger throughput above three and a half million, or any other airport or group of airports that the Central Government notifies. AERA determines tariffs for aeronautical services at these airports, along with development fees and the passenger service fee, and monitors performance standards. Airports outside the definition are not subject to AERA's tariff determination.
How long do I have to appeal an AERA tariff order?
Thirty days from the date on which the appellant receives a copy of the order, under Section 18 of the AERA Act. The appeal goes to the TDSAT, which may admit it after 30 days if there was sufficient cause, and which is to try to dispose of it within 90 days. From the Tribunal, an appeal lies to the Supreme Court within 90 days on the grounds in Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (Section 31). In 2024 the Supreme Court held that AERA itself can appeal against the Tribunal's orders under Section 31.
These answers are educational summaries; they are not legal advice on any individual matter.
A serious question deserves a read brief.
Conferences are by appointment at G-46, Basement, Greater Kailash III, New Delhi. The principal reads the correspondence.
This page gives general information about the work of Lokesh Bhardwaj Law Offices, as permitted under the Bar Council of India Rules. It is not legal advice, and it does not create an advocate-client relationship. LBLO acts in a matter only on an engagement agreed in writing.
Last reviewed: 16/11/2026. Lokesh Bhardwaj Law Offices.
Law stated as at 16/11/2026.
← All Practice Areas