Stacked against the buyer.
The structural imbalance in India's builder-buyer disputes.
For most Indian families, buying a home is the single largest financial decision they will ever make. It is also, increasingly, the decision that exposes them to the longest-running and most asymmetric form of commercial litigation our system produces.
Despite a growing body of consumer-protection law, a dedicated regulator in RERA, and a bankruptcy route through the IBC, the buyer of an under-construction unit in India continues to bear a disproportionate share of the project's risks. This article examines why that is, and what realistic options remain on the table when things go wrong.
1. The GST Question: A Tax with No Beneficiary on the Buyer's Side
When a buyer purchases a ready-to-move-in property backed by a completion or occupation certificate, no GST is levied. The moment that same buyer chooses an under-construction unit, GST becomes payable, currently at 5% for standard housing and 1% for affordable housing, both without the benefit of input tax credit flowing to the buyer.
The consequence is straightforward. The buyer who chooses to invest early, often precisely when the developer is hungriest for capital, is penalised with an additional cost that no other party in the transaction recovers. The builder cannot pass on the credit. The buyer cannot offset it. The amount simply moves to the exchequer. The buyer who took the greater risk pays the higher bill, and nothing about that exchange is reciprocated in the form of stronger statutory protection.
2. The Black Money Problem Nobody Wants to Discuss
There is a quieter problem that runs underneath nearly every property dispute in India, and the legal community discusses it far less candidly than it should. A significant portion of high-value property transactions, both in purchase and resale, continues to involve a cash component alongside the cheque component. Buyers and sellers often regard this as a market norm. They forget that the moment a dispute reaches a court of law, the buyer can prove only what the buyer can document.
Cash paid leaves no admissible trail. The cheque component becomes the ceiling of what is recoverable. The builder's books, often structured to absorb this irregularity through complex inter-company adjustments, remain unshaken. In effect, the buyer who participated in the cash component as a market practice ends up underwriting the builder's protection at the time of dispute. This is a structural risk that no buyer should accept without first understanding its full legal consequence.
3. The Delay Culture: From Exception to Norm
Delay in possession is no longer an unfortunate exception in Indian real estate; it has become a defining feature. The reasons are layered, and not all of them lie at the builder's door:
- Resource constraints, including water shortages and labour disruptions, can genuinely affect the pace of construction.
- Authority-imposed restrictions, such as construction bans during pollution emergencies or environmental clearances pending review, can stall a project for months.
- Changes in the political dispensation at the state level frequently alter the policy benefits, FAR concessions, or development incentives previously extended to a project. A benefit granted by one government is not always honoured by its successor.
- Statutory or regulatory shifts, whether in zoning, environmental compliance, or municipal approvals, can derail timelines that were realistic when the project was conceived.
None of these reasons, however, alter the fundamental fact that the buyer, not the builder, absorbs the cost of delay. The buyer continues to pay rent on a different premises, services a home loan on a flat that does not yet exist, and watches the time value of the invested capital quietly erode.
4. Siphoning of Funds and the Fiduciary Question
The most serious harm to a buyer does not come from delay alone. It comes from the diversion of project funds. A builder who collects payments earmarked for Project A, and uses them to subsidise Project B or to cover unrelated corporate obligations, hollows out the very project the buyer paid into.
The builder stands in a fiduciary position towards the buyer. To divert funds is not merely a contractual breach. It is a breach of the trust character of the relationship itself.
The Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, popularly known as RERA, was meant to address precisely this concern through its escrow requirement, where 70% of project receipts must be deposited in a designated account and used only for that project. This was the heart of the statute. Yet enforcement has been uneven, regulator capacity has been overwhelmed, and many projects pre-dating RERA continue to operate outside its full reach. The promise of RERA, as a structural cure to the siphoning problem, remains substantially unrealised.
5. Quality of Construction: The Missing Specifications
A separate but equally damaging problem is the absence of clear, contractually agreed quality standards. Most builder-buyer agreements speak in broad, marketing-oriented language about "premium fittings," "imported marble," or "branded sanitaryware," without naming brands, grades, thicknesses, or measurable specifications. When the flat is finally handed over and the buyer notices that what was delivered does not match what was promised, the absence of specifics in the contract becomes the builder's strongest defence.
The lesson here is preventive. Specification annexures should be negotiated and incorporated at the booking stage itself, naming brands, models, and grades wherever possible.
6. Forums Available to the Aggrieved Buyer
When something does go wrong, whether stalled construction, unreasonable delay, deviation from sanctioned plans, or substandard delivery, the buyer is not without remedy. Indian law offers several distinct forums, each with its own character.
Consumer Protection Act, 2019. The consumer commissions remain a significant forum for individual buyers seeking compensation, refund, or possession with interest. The pecuniary jurisdiction is layered across district, state, and national commissions. The Supreme Court has consistently held that a homebuyer is a "consumer" within the meaning of the Act, and that builder defaults attract deficiency-in-service liability.
RERA. State Real Estate Regulatory Authorities offer a faster, more specialised route for registered projects, with the ability to direct refund with interest, possession with delay compensation, and project-level remedial action. RERA is generally the first port of call for projects within its registration ambit.
NCLT and the IBC route. Following the 2018 amendment to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, and the Supreme Court's affirmation in Pioneer Urban Land and Infrastructure Ltd. v. Union of India, allottees of real estate projects are recognised as financial creditors. A group of buyers meeting the prescribed threshold can move the National Company Law Tribunal seeking initiation of the corporate insolvency resolution process. Once admitted, an Interim Resolution Professional takes control, the builder's management is displaced, and a resolution plan is invited. In appropriate cases, this path can produce outcomes that no individual consumer forum can match, including takeover by a new developer and project completion under court supervision.
Civil suits and writ jurisdiction. These continue to play a role in specific situations, particularly where title questions, specific performance, or constitutional issues arise.
7. Choosing the Right Path: A Note for the Buyer
The "best" forum is never the same in every case. It is a function of the buyer's own situation as much as the builder's. A buyer who has lost faith in the project and wants an exit, with a refund and reasonable interest, may be better served by a consumer commission or RERA proceeding. A buyer who has invested in a project that retains commercial value, and who wants the project completed rather than wound up, may be poorly served by initiating insolvency proceedings, which can dilute equity and stretch timelines further. A group of buyers in a clearly unviable project, where the builder has already siphoned funds and walked away, may find that the IBC route is the only realistic chance of seeing either possession or recovery.
Time value of money is not a textbook abstraction. It is the actual cost of every passing year on a buyer's locked-in capital. A refund secured five years late, even with statutory interest, is rarely the equivalent of a refund secured promptly. Equally, an insolvency proceeding initiated in haste, against a builder with a recoverable balance sheet, may convert a rescuable situation into an unrescuable one.
A Closing Note
The Indian real estate sector has come a long way from the era when the buyer's only hope was the builder's goodwill. Statutes now exist; forums now exist; precedents now exist. What remains uneven is the structural balance between the parties. The buyer continues to pay first, prove later, and wait longest.
If you are facing a builder dispute, whether the issue is delay, deviation from sanctioned plans, refund of paid amounts, possession with compensation, or a project that appears to be heading towards insolvency, the right course of action depends on a careful, fact-specific assessment. No single forum is universally the right answer, and no single template suits every buyer.
Two-minute explainers on the questions these essays raise.
The Office publishes short video versions of its long-form writing. Subscribe to be notified when the explainer for this article is released.
Sources and provisions referred to
Statutes and rules
- Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016: Section 18
- Consumer Protection Act, 2019
- Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, and its 2018 amendment
Cases
- Pioneer Urban Land and Infrastructure Ltd. v. Union of India
Frequently asked questions
What can a homebuyer do when a builder delays possession?
Three forums are realistically available, and the choice among them is the first strategic decision. The RERA authority can order refund with interest or possession with delay interest against a registered project. The consumer commission can award compensation for deficiency of service and is sometimes the better route for a buyer who wants possession plus damages. The NCLT under the IBC becomes relevant where the developer is insolvent, though it is a collective remedy with collective consequences. The article works through how the facts of the project should drive the choice.
Why are builder-buyer disputes described as asymmetric?
Because the buyer performs first and the builder performs later, if at all. The buyer commits the largest payment of his life in advance, bears GST on instalments without any corresponding input benefit, and carries the financing cost of delay, while the project's funds, timeline, and construction quality remain in the developer's control. The agreement is drafted by the developer's lawyers, the delay clauses favour the developer, and the buyer's leverage begins only when he litigates competently.
Has RERA fixed the imbalance between builders and buyers?
It has improved disclosure, created a dedicated regulator, and given buyers a forum that did not exist before 2016, and the article gives the Act credit for each of these. But the structural imbalance survives: registrations lapse, orders need execution, and a regulator's decree is only as good as its enforcement. The article's counsel is that a buyer should treat RERA as a powerful instrument to be wielded strategically, not as a guardian who will act of his own motion.
Can a buyer get a refund with interest from a builder?
Yes. Where the builder fails to deliver in accordance with the agreement, the buyer may withdraw from the project and claim refund of the entire amount paid, with interest at the prescribed rate, under Section 18 of the RERA. A buyer who chooses to stay in the project is entitled to interest for every month of delay until possession. Which election serves the buyer better depends on the project's realistic completion prospects, and the article cautions against electing refund from a developer who has no money to refund.
What happens to homebuyers when a builder goes into insolvency?
Homebuyers are recognised as financial creditors under the IBC, which entitles them to representation in the committee of creditors through an authorised representative. That recognition is valuable, but the article is candid about its limits: insolvency is a collective process, resolution takes time, and allottees may face haircuts alongside banks. For an individual buyer, the IBC is sometimes the only remedy left, but it is rarely the remedy of choice while the developer is still solvent enough to answer a RERA or consumer decree.
These answers are educational summaries of the article above; they are not legal advice on any individual matter.
Corrections: if you find an error of law or fact in this article, write to contact@lokeshbhardwajlawoffices.com with the subject 'Correction'. Corrections are made in the text and noted here with the date.
This article is offered as general legal commentary and does not constitute legal advice. References are to the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, and connected enactments and judgements as in force on the date of writing. Readers facing concrete disputes should consult qualified counsel.
← Articles