Lokesh Bhardwaj Law Offices ← All Practice Areas
Lokesh Bhardwaj Law Offices · Advocates and Legal Consultants, New Delhi · lokeshbhardwajlawoffices.com
Practice Area

Medical Negligence: Consumer, Civil and Criminal Remedies, the Standard of Care and the Medical Council

When treatment goes wrong, the law offers four separate routes: a consumer complaint, a civil suit for damages, a criminal case, and a complaint to the medical council, each with its own test and its own evidence.

In brief

Terms you will hear

Deficiency
any fault, imperfection, shortcoming or inadequacy in the quality, nature and manner of performance of a service, including any act of negligence causing loss or injury to the consumer (Section 2(11), Consumer Protection Act, 2019).
Bolam test
a doctor is not negligent if he acted in accordance with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of medical men skilled in that art, from an English case of 1957 adopted in Jacob Mathew.
Gross negligence
negligence of a very high degree, which alone can found criminal liability; simple lack of care can found only civil liability.
Res ipsa loquitur
'the thing speaks for itself': where the harm would not ordinarily occur with proper care, such as a swab left inside, the burden shifts to the doctor or hospital to show care was taken. It has limited use in criminal cases.
Case sheet and discharge summary
the hospital's record of admission, notes, orders, investigations, procedures and discharge, which the patient is entitled to obtain.
Specialist opinion
the opinion of an independent doctor in the relevant branch on whether the treatment met the accepted standard.
Medical board
a panel of doctors, usually from a government institution, to which a court, commission or the police may refer the record for an opinion.
State Medical Council
the body that keeps the State medical register and takes disciplinary action for professional or ethical misconduct; in Delhi, the Delhi Medical Council.
Ethics and Medical Registration Board
the autonomous board of the National Medical Commission that hears practitioners' appeals against State Medical Council action (Section 30(3), National Medical Commission Act, 2019).

In detail

This guide explains the four routes, the legal test of negligence, how negligence is proved, and the disciplinary complaint. Consumer complaints in general are on the consumer cases page, and the documents to collect are on the consumer complaint checklist.

Medical negligence in consumer, civil and criminal fora

The consumer complaint

In Indian Medical Association v. V.P. Shantha, (1995) 6 SCC 651, the Supreme Court held that services rendered by medical practitioners and hospitals for consideration are a "service" under consumer protection law, while services rendered entirely free of charge, and contracts of personal service, are outside it. The principle continues to be applied under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. In February 2026 the Supreme Court issued notice on a public interest petition seeking to exclude medical services from the 2019 Act; V.P. Shantha remains binding unless a larger Bench decides otherwise.

The complaint is filed in the District, State or National Commission according to the value of the services paid for: up to Rs. 50 lakh, above Rs. 50 lakh up to Rs. 2 crore, and above Rs. 2 crore. It must be filed within two years of the cause of action, with condonation for sufficient cause (Section 69; see the consumer limitation page). Where the effect of negligence is latent, the cause of action arises when the patient discovers the harm or could, with reasonable diligence, have discovered it; where the effect is patent, it arises on the date of the act (V.N. Shrikhande v. Anita Sena Fernandes, (2011) 1 SCC 53). The filing fee is fixed by Rule 7 of the Consumer Protection (Consumer Disputes Redressal Commissions) Rules, 2020: nil where the value paid is up to Rs. 5 lakh, rising in slabs to Rs. 7,500 above Rs. 10 crore.

The complaint is usually made against both the treating doctor and the hospital, and the hospital's insurer is often joined. It states the facts in date order, the specific failures alleged, the harm and the compensation claimed, with the records annexed.

The civil suit for damages

A suit for damages in tort is filed in the civil court. It is preferred where the case raises complicated questions that need extensive oral evidence, where the claim is large, or where the service was free and so outside consumer law. The Supreme Court in V.P. Shantha recognised that in complicated cases a complainant may be asked to approach the civil court. A suit carries court fee on the amount claimed and is slower than a consumer complaint, but the court can examine witnesses at length.

The criminal complaint

Death caused by a rash or negligent act is punishable under Section 106(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (formerly Section 304A IPC) with up to five years and fine; where the act is done by a registered medical practitioner while performing a medical procedure, the term may extend to two years, with fine. A registered medical practitioner is one with a recognised qualification whose name is on the National or a State Medical Register (Explanation to Section 106(1)).

In Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, (2005) 6 SCC 1, the Supreme Court held that for criminal liability the negligence must be gross, and laid down guidelines that continue to apply:

How to have an FIR registered or a complaint taken up is explained on the page for complainants.

Choosing and combining routes

The routes answer different questions. The consumer and civil routes decide compensation on the civil standard. The criminal route decides guilt on the criminal standard and the higher threshold of gross negligence. The council decides professional misconduct. They can be pursued together, and a finding in one is not automatically binding in another, although the record of one is often used in the others. The choice depends on the evidence, the amount, the time already passed and what the family wants from the process.

The standard of care

The test

Jacob Mathew summarised the law. A professional may be held liable for negligence on one of two findings: that he did not possess the skill he professed to have, or that he did not exercise, with reasonable competence in the given case, the skill he did possess. The standard is that of an ordinary competent person exercising ordinary skill in that profession, not that of the most skilled practitioner. The Bolam test applies in India: a doctor is not negligent if he acted in accordance with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of medical opinion skilled in that art.

Room for judgment

In V. Kishan Rao v. Nikhil Super Speciality Hospital, Civil Appeal No. 2641 of 2010, decided on 08/03/2010, the Supreme Court followed Jacob Mathew and the Bolam test, and noted that in diagnosis and treatment there is ample scope for genuine difference of opinion; a doctor is not negligent merely because his conclusion differs from that of other doctors. The question is whether he failed in a way no doctor of ordinary skill acting with ordinary care would have failed. The duty of care covers deciding whether to undertake the case, deciding what treatment to give, and the administration of that treatment.

Civil and criminal negligence

What is negligence in civil law is not necessarily negligence in criminal law. For an offence, the negligence must be gross or of a very high degree, and the accused must have done something, or failed to do something, that no medical professional in his ordinary senses and prudence would have done or failed to do (Jacob Mathew). A case that fails as a prosecution may still succeed as a claim for compensation.

Typical allegations

Evidence and medical boards

The records come first

The case sheet, doctors' and nurses' notes, consent forms, investigation reports, operation and anaesthesia notes, the discharge summary or death summary, bills and, in a death, the post-mortem report decide most cases. Ask for the records in writing as soon as possible and keep proof of the request. Under Regulation 1.3.2 of the Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002, a request for medical records by the patient, an authorised attendant or the legal authorities must be acknowledged and the documents issued within 72 hours; Regulation 1.3.1 requires records of indoor patients to be kept for three years from the start of treatment. These 2002 Regulations remain in force, because the National Medical Commission's 2023 conduct regulations were placed in abeyance in August 2023.

Specialist opinion

Whether a specialist opinion is needed depends on the forum and the facts. In a consumer case, V. Kishan Rao holds that the Commission must first decide whether the case is complicated enough to require it; a mechanical rule that every case needs specialist evidence would make the remedy illusory. The Commission may allow either side to lead such evidence, is not bound to accept it, and decides the question as one of fact and law. In a criminal case, Jacob Mathew requires a credible opinion of another competent doctor with a private complaint and an independent opinion before the police proceed. In Delhi, the police commonly refer such complaints to the Delhi Medical Council for an opinion.

Medical boards

A court, a Commission or the police may refer the record to a board of doctors, usually from a government institution, for an opinion on the treatment. A board's opinion is evidence, not a verdict; it can be questioned, and its members can be examined where the forum allows. Supplying the board with the complete record and a clear list of questions makes its report more useful.

Res ipsa loquitur

Where negligence is evident, such as a mismatched transfusion or a swab left in the abdomen, the principle of res ipsa loquitur applies: the thing speaks for itself, and the doctor or hospital must show that due care was taken (V. Kishan Rao, following earlier decisions). In criminal law it has only limited application (Jacob Mathew).

Common mistakes

Complaints to the medical council

The framework

The National Medical Commission Act, 2019 leaves disciplinary action for professional or ethical misconduct to the State Medical Councils where a State law gives them that power, acting in accordance with the regulations and guidelines under the 2019 Act (Section 30(2)). Where no State Medical Council exists, the Ethics and Medical Registration Board receives the complaints. Before any action, including a monetary penalty, the practitioner must be given a hearing (provisos to Section 30(2)).

In Delhi

Complaints against doctors registered in Delhi are made to the Delhi Medical Council, constituted under the Delhi Medical Council Act, 1997. Its Disciplinary Committee examines the complaint with the written statements of the doctor and the hospital, and its decision, such as a warning or the removal of the doctor's name from the State Medical Register for a period, is placed before the Council for confirmation. The Council also gives opinions to the police on complaints of negligence referred to it.

Appeals

A practitioner aggrieved by action taken by a State Medical Council may appeal to the Ethics and Medical Registration Board, whose decision binds the State Council unless a second appeal is made (Section 30(3)). A further appeal lies to the National Medical Commission within sixty days of communication of the Board's decision (Section 30(4)). Both sub-sections give the appeal to the medical practitioner or professional; a complainant dissatisfied with the Council's decision has used the writ jurisdiction of the High Court.

What the council can and cannot do

The council decides whether the doctor committed professional misconduct and can warn, suspend or remove the doctor's name from the register. It does not award compensation to the patient. Its findings are not binding on a Consumer Commission or a court, but its record and reasons are often placed before them.

Questions people ask

Can I file a consumer case against a hospital for medical negligence?

Yes, if the treatment was a service for consideration. In Indian Medical Association v. V.P. Shantha, (1995) 6 SCC 651, the Supreme Court held that paid medical services are a service under consumer law, while services rendered entirely free of charge are outside it. The complaint goes to the District Commission where the value paid is up to Rs. 50 lakh, the State Commission above that up to Rs. 2 crore, and the National Commission above Rs. 2 crore. You must show a deficiency in service, meaning a failure to meet the standard of a reasonably competent practitioner, usually through the records and medical opinion.

Is there a time limit for a medical negligence complaint?

A consumer complaint must be filed within two years from the date on which the cause of action arises (Section 69, Consumer Protection Act, 2019), and later only on sufficient cause. In medical cases the Supreme Court held in V.N. Shrikhande v. Anita Sena Fernandes, (2011) 1 SCC 53 that where the effect of negligence is patent, time runs from the act; where it is latent, from the date the patient discovered the harm or could have discovered it with reasonable diligence. In that case a patient who suffered pain for nine years without consulting anyone could not rely on the later discovery.

Do I need another doctor's opinion before filing a case?

It depends on the route. For a criminal complaint against a doctor, Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, (2005) 6 SCC 1 requires the complainant to produce a credible opinion of another competent doctor supporting the charge, and the police to obtain an independent medical opinion before proceeding. For a consumer complaint, V. Kishan Rao v. Nikhil Super Speciality Hospital holds that specialist evidence is needed only where the case is complicated; obvious failures can be decided on the records. In practice, an independent opinion obtained before filing helps in every forum.

Can a doctor be arrested after a patient dies during surgery?

Only on strict conditions. In Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, (2005) 6 SCC 1, the Supreme Court held that a doctor accused of rashness or negligence should not be arrested in a routine manner simply because a charge has been levelled, but only where arrest is necessary for the investigation or to secure the doctor's presence. The investigating officer should first obtain an independent medical opinion applying the Bolam test. Criminal liability needs gross negligence, of a degree no ordinarily prudent doctor would show, not an error of judgment or an unfortunate outcome.

What punishment does the BNS provide for death caused by medical negligence?

Section 106(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, which replaced Section 304A of the IPC, punishes causing death by a rash or negligent act not amounting to culpable homicide with imprisonment up to five years and fine. Where the act is done by a registered medical practitioner while performing a medical procedure, the imprisonment may extend to two years, with fine. A registered medical practitioner is one with a qualification recognised under the National Medical Commission Act, 2019 whose name is on the National or a State Medical Register. The Jacob Mathew safeguards on complaints and arrest continue to apply.

How do I get my medical records from a hospital?

Make a written request to the hospital, signed by the patient or, after death, by a family member, and keep proof of delivery. Regulation 1.3.2 of the Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002 requires a request for records by the patient, an authorised attendant or the legal authorities to be acknowledged and the documents issued within 72 hours. Ask for the complete case sheet, notes, consent forms, investigation reports, operation notes and discharge or death summary. A refusal can itself be raised before the medical council and the consumer forum.

Is a hospital responsible for the negligence of its doctors and nurses?

Generally yes. A hospital answers for the negligence of the doctors, nurses and staff it engages in the course of their work, and directly for its own failures, such as inadequate staff, equipment, monitoring or emergency arrangements. That is why a consumer complaint or suit is usually filed against both the hospital and the treating doctor. Where the doctor was a visiting consultant, the terms of engagement and the admission papers matter. The hospital's insurer is often joined, and the hospital's own records of who attended the patient, and when, become central evidence.

What can the Delhi Medical Council do on my complaint?

The Delhi Medical Council deals with complaints of professional or ethical misconduct against doctors registered in Delhi. Its Disciplinary Committee examines the complaint with the written statements of the doctor and the hospital and decides whether misconduct is made out; its decisions, such as a warning or removal of the doctor's name from the register for a period, are confirmed by the Council. The Council does not award compensation. The doctor must be heard before any action (Section 30(2), National Medical Commission Act, 2019), and compensation must be sought separately before a Consumer Commission or a civil court.

Can I appeal if the medical council rejects my complaint?

Section 30(3) and (4) of the National Medical Commission Act, 2019 give a right of appeal to the Ethics and Medical Registration Board, and then to the National Medical Commission within sixty days, to the medical practitioner or professional aggrieved by the council's action. They do not in terms give the complainant an appeal. Complainants dissatisfied with a council's decision have approached the High Court under Article 226. The rejection does not prevent a consumer complaint or a civil suit, which are decided on their own evidence.

What does res ipsa loquitur mean in a medical negligence case?

It means 'the thing speaks for itself'. Where the harm is of a kind that does not ordinarily happen if proper care is taken, such as a swab or instrument left inside after surgery or a mismatched blood transfusion, negligence is inferred and the doctor or hospital must show that due care was taken. The Supreme Court applied the principle in consumer cases in V. Kishan Rao v. Nikhil Super Speciality Hospital, decided on 08/03/2010. In criminal cases, Jacob Mathew held that it has only limited application and cannot by itself establish criminal negligence.

These answers are educational summaries; they are not legal advice on any individual matter.

Engagement

A serious question deserves a read brief.

Conferences are by appointment at G-46, Basement, Greater Kailash III, New Delhi. The principal reads the correspondence.

Disclaimer This page describes areas in which the Office accepts work; it is informational, published in compliance with the Bar Council of India Rules, Chapter II, Part VI, Rule 36, and is not an advertisement or solicitation. Nothing here is legal advice, and no lawyer-client relationship arises from reading it.

This page gives general information about the work of Lokesh Bhardwaj Law Offices, as permitted under the Bar Council of India Rules. It is not legal advice, and it does not create an advocate-client relationship. LBLO acts in a matter only on an engagement agreed in writing.

Law stated as at 16/11/2026.

WhatsApp