Lokesh Bhardwaj Law Offices ← Articles
Lokesh Bhardwaj Law Offices · Advocates and Legal Consultants, New Delhi · lokeshbhardwajlawoffices.com
Customs & Economic Offences · Explainer

Violation, seizure and the way back.

What actually happens between the green channel and the courtroom, and where the law protects you.

12 September 202636 minute read
Last reviewed: 17/10/2026
DECLARE, SEIZE, ADJUDICATE, APPEAL GREEN RED SECTION 110(1) the pouch with a number on it SIX MONTHS SEIZURE SHOW CAUSE ORDER APPEAL no notice, goods go back Section 124 Sections 125, 128, 129-A every protection in the sequence is locked to a date
The seizure starts a clock. Six months without a notice under Section 124, and the goods must go back.

You land at Delhi after two years abroad. You are tired. There are two exits, one green and one red, and nobody has explained the difference. You take the green one, because everyone does. Thirty seconds later an officer asks you to step aside, and the chain around your neck is in a plastic pouch with a number on it.

What follows is not arbitrary. It is a sequence set out in the Customs Act, 1962, running from that pouch to a show cause notice, to an order, sometimes to an arrest, and eventually to a court. Almost every protection in that sequence is locked to a date, and most people discover the dates after they have passed.

This is a map of the whole thing. It is written for the person standing at the counter as much as for the lawyer who will be called the next morning.

I. Why the Act exists at all

A customs frontier is not a wall. It is a filter. Every consignment and every passenger crossing it is asked three questions at once: is this thing allowed in or out at all, has the correct duty been paid on it, and is the person telling the truth about it.

The Customs Act, 1962 is the machinery that asks those three questions and punishes a false answer. Its purposes are worth separating, because the whole architecture of violation and penalty follows from them.

That single clause turns the Customs Act into the enforcement arm for narcotics law, arms law, wildlife law, foreign trade policy, hazardous waste rules and intellectual property.

Security and the economy come third. Contraband entering outside the fiscal system distorts prices, funds parallel economies and, at the sharper end, funds worse things. That premise is what the preventive detention overlay in the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 (COFEPOSA) rests on.

Now the structural point that explains everything that follows. The Act operates on three separate objects, and imposes three separate liabilities:

These are cumulative, not alternative. Section 127 says so in terms: an adjudicating officer's order of confiscation or penalty does not prevent punishment under Chapter XVI or any other law. Confiscation of the gold, a penalty on the passenger and a prosecution under Section 135 can all follow from one walk through one door, and a COFEPOSA detention can sit on top of all three.

II. What counts as a "violation"

The Act does not define a general offence of "customs violation". It works by two exhaustive lists of circumstances in which goods become liable to confiscation, and then hangs personal liability off those lists.

2.1 Improper importation: Section 111

Seventeen clauses, (a) to (q). Grouped by what they are really about:

2.2 Improper exportation: Section 113

Section 113 mirrors it for export goods, at clauses (a) to (l): export from an unappointed port, through an unnotified route, contrary to a prohibition, concealment in a package, loading in breach of Sections 33 or 34, goods not included in or in excess of the entry or baggage declaration, goods not corresponding in value or material particular with the entry, drawback goods that do not match the information furnished for fixation of the drawback rate, goods entered for drawback on which import duty was never paid, and goods cleared for export but not loaded through the exporter's wilful act, negligence or default.

A drafting point that is frequently missed: in 2003 the words "dutiable or prohibited" were deleted from clauses (c), (e), (f), (g) and (h) of Section 113. Export-side confiscation is therefore considerably wider than import-side confiscation: any goods, not merely dutiable or prohibited goods, can be confiscated for those breaches.

2.3 What it costs the person

The Section 112 and 114 scales are worth stating precisely, because they were amended in 2015 and the older figures still circulate:

One provision to check in every order: Section 114A carries a proviso that where a penalty is levied under Section 114A, no penalty shall be levied under Section 112 or Section 114. Departments routinely impose both. That is a clean ground of appeal, and a pure question of law.

2.4 Why a small seizure becomes a large order

Four provisions extend confiscation beyond the offending goods themselves:

III. "Smuggling" does not mean what you think

Section 2(39) is a definition by reference, and it is deceptively wide: "smuggling", in relation to any goods, means any act or omission which will render such goods liable to confiscation under Section 111 or Section 113. Read that again. There is no requirement of concealment, and none of dishonesty.

First, smuggling has nothing to do with stealth. A passenger who honestly forgets a laptop, an importer who claims a preferential rate of duty without holding the origin documentation, and an exporter whose shipping bill overstates value in a material particular are all, on the statutory language, engaged in smuggling.

The word carries no requirement of mens rea at the confiscation stage. Second, smuggling is not itself an offence. It is a defined term used elsewhere. The criminal offence is in Section 135, which does require knowledge or fraud. The gap between the two, wide confiscation liability without intent and narrow criminal liability with it, is the single most important structural feature of the Act, and it is where most defences live.

Third, "prohibited goods" is narrower than it sounds. Section 2(33) defines prohibited goods as goods whose import or export is prohibited under the Act or any other law, but excludes goods in respect of which the conditions of a permitted import or export have been complied with. Compliance with conditions converts prohibited goods into ordinary goods. This is why so much customs litigation turns on whether a restriction is a prohibition or merely a condition, and the answer decides whether redemption under Section 125 is mandatory or discretionary.

What actually gets smuggled

In rough order of what one sees at Indian ports and airports: gold, in ornaments, bars, biscuits, paste, capsules, dust and increasingly in machine parts and mixed alloys; foreign currency on the export side, engaging the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 in parallel; narcotic drugs, engaging the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985; cigarettes and tobacco, driven by high domestic taxation; electronics, phones and high-value watches; wildlife and wildlife articles; arms, ammunition and dual-use or SCOMET-listed items; counterfeit and intellectual property infringing consignments; and a large volume of commercial fraud that is legally "smuggling" but looks like paperwork, meaning mis-declaration of description, value, quantity or origin, fraudulent drawback claims, abuse of conditional exemptions and circular trading to obtain scrips.

Gold dominates because it carries duty, is compact, is liquid, and India is among the world's largest consumers. Which is also the uncomfortable point that no enforcement agency can fix: when the duty wedge is large, the incentive to smuggle is large.

IV. The green channel: how a walk becomes a confiscation

The green and red channel system is not a courtesy. It is a declaration mechanism with statutory teeth.

Section 77 requires the owner of any baggage to declare its contents to the proper officer. Section 78 fixes the rate of duty by reference to the date that declaration is made. Section 79 allows the proper officer to pass free of duty used personal effects and articles for the passenger's use or bona fide gifts, within limits set by rules. Section 81 is the regulation-making power.

Walking through the green channel is treated as a declaration that you carry nothing beyond the free allowance and nothing prohibited or restricted. If that is untrue, the goods are "not included in the declaration made under Section 77" and become liable to confiscation under Section 111(l), or do not correspond with it in value or particular and fall under Section 111(m). Penalty under Section 112 follows, and if the thresholds are met, prosecution under Section 135 and arrest under Section 104.

Section 80 is the provision almost nobody uses. Where baggage contains a dutiable or prohibited article in respect of which a true declaration has been made, the proper officer may, at the passenger's request, detain it and return it when the passenger leaves India. It is a genuine safe harbour, and it is available only to the passenger who declares.

The Baggage Rules, 2026

The Baggage Rules, 2016 have been superseded. The Baggage Rules, 2026 were notified vide Notification No. 14/2026-Customs (N.T.) dated 01/02/2026 under Section 79, and came into force on 02/02/2026, together with new declaration and processing regulations and a master circular consolidating 35 earlier circulars.

Passengers arriving by land borders have no general duty-free allowance. Transfer of residence benefits are a single rationalised list, capped at Rs. 1.5 lakh for a stay up to 12 months, Rs. 3 lakh for one to two years and Rs. 7.5 lakh above two years. One new laptop is duty free for a passenger above 18 years, outside the general allowance.

The change that matters most for the gold cases: the jewellery allowance is now purely weight based, the old value caps having been removed. Up to 40 grams for a female passenger and up to 20 grams for any other passenger, for eligible returning residents and tourists of Indian origin after more than a year abroad. Gold or silver in any form other than ornaments has no free allowance at all.

Does the channel system work?

Two things are true at once, and both should be said.

As a design, it is sound. It is impossible to physically examine every passenger at Delhi, Mumbai and Bengaluru without shutting the airports. Self-declaration backed by profiling, non-intrusive scanning and serious consequences for a false declaration is the only workable model, and it is used worldwide.

The enforcement of it in India, however, has generated a body of case law that is not flattering, and that is dealt with at Stage 5 below.

V. Stage by stage: what actually happens

Stage 1: Interception and search

Stage 2: Seizure, and the clock it starts

Section 110(2) is the date to diarise. If no notice under Section 124(a) is given within six months of seizure, the goods must be returned. The Principal Commissioner or Commissioner may, for reasons recorded in writing, extend by a further six months, and must inform the person from whom the goods were seized before the expiry of the original period. Where provisional release has been ordered under Section 110-A, the six month period does not apply.

That extension is not administrative housekeeping. In Assistant Collector of Customs v. Charan Das Malhotra the Supreme Court held the power under the proviso to be quasi-judicial, or at any rate requiring a judicial approach; that it cannot be exercised mechanically or as a matter of routine; that the burden lies on the department to show sufficient cause; and that the person concerned must be heard before the extension is granted, because the right to restoration accrues on the expiry of the initial six months and is defeated by the extension.

Section 110(5) permits provisional attachment of a bank account with the approval of the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, for up to six months, extendable by a further six with reasons recorded and intimation to the account holder.

Stage 3: Getting the goods back in the meantime

Under Section 110-A, goods, documents, things and provisionally attached bank accounts may be released to the owner or account holder pending the order of the adjudicating authority, on a bond in the proper form with such security and conditions as the adjudicating authority may require. This is the most under-used remedy in customs practice. An application under Section 110-A, and a writ against an unreasoned refusal or an extortionate bond condition, will often achieve in weeks what the appellate route achieves in years.

Stage 4: Statements, and why they are so dangerous

Section 107 allows an empowered officer, during an enquiry connected with smuggling, to require production of documents and to examine persons acquainted with the facts. Section 108 is the workhorse: any gazetted officer of customs may summon any person to give evidence or produce documents; all persons summoned are bound to attend and bound to state the truth; and every such enquiry is deemed a judicial proceeding within the meaning of Sections 193 and 228 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.

The consequences should be explained to any client before he attends, because they are counter-intuitive:

Against all that, Radhika Agarwal confirms that a person under interrogation may have an advocate present within visual but not hearing distance, following Senior Intelligence Officer, DRI v. Jugal Kishore Samra, and that Section 41-D of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 applies, giving an arrested person the right to meet an advocate of his choice during, though not throughout, interrogation.

Stage 5: The show cause notice, and the form at the counter

Section 124 is mandatory. No order of confiscation and no penalty may be made unless the owner or person concerned:

The first proviso permits the notice and the representation to be oral at the request of the person concerned. That proviso is the hinge on which the entire airport litigation turns, because in practice it has become a pre-printed form pushed across a counter at two in the morning, by which the passenger appears to give up both his notice and his hearing.

The Delhi High Court has held repeatedly that such standard waivers do not satisfy the proviso. In Amit Kumar v. Commissioner of Customs a Division Bench held that printed waivers fundamentally violate the rights of the persons affected, that any oral waiver must be a proper declaration consciously signed, that even then a hearing must be afforded, and directed the department to discontinue the practice. That direction has had to be repeated in case after case since.

If you sign nothing else that night, understand what that form is.

Stage 6: Who has to prove what

Section 123 reverses the burden. Where goods to which the section applies are seized in the reasonable belief that they are smuggled, the burden of proving that they are not lies on the person from whose possession they were seized and on any other person claiming ownership. The section applies to gold and manufactures thereof, watches, and any other class of goods notified by the Central Government.

Two points of practice. The reasonable belief is a condition precedent to the reversal, is justiciable, and must exist at the time of seizure. And Section 123 reverses the burden on the question of smuggling only, not on the identity of the offender, not on the quantum of penalty, and not on mens rea for prosecution.

Stage 7: Adjudication

Stage 8: The order, and the date that kills

An order in original in a seizure case typically does four things at once, and each should be examined separately on appeal:

Then Section 125(3) sets a trap. Where the redemption fine is not paid within 120 days from the date the option is given, the option becomes void, unless an appeal against the order is pending. People lose the right to redeem their own property while negotiating politely with the department. Diarise it the day the order is received.

Stage 9: How the order reaches you

Service is governed by Section 153, which prescribes five modes:

Sub-section (2) deems service on the date of tender, publication, affixture or uploading; sub-section (3) deems a postal communication received at the expiry of the period normally taken in transit unless the contrary is proved.

Two consequences. Limitation for appeal runs from the date of communication, not the date the order bears. And an order not served in a prescribed mode is not communicated at all, which is a complete answer to a plea of delay. Where the department holds an email address and a mobile number taken at the time of detention, as it now routinely does at airports, it cannot simultaneously say it was unable to serve.

VI. Arrest and prosecution

The power, and its limits

Under Section 104(1), an officer of customs empowered by general or special order of the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, who has reason to believe that a person has committed an offence punishable under Section 132, 133, 135, 135-A or 136, may arrest him and shall, as soon as may be, inform him of the grounds. Sub-section (2) requires production before a magistrate without unnecessary delay.

The cognizability and bailability provisions have been rewritten three times since 2011. The current position is this.

Cognizable, under Section 104(4): offences relating to prohibited goods; evasion or attempted evasion of duty exceeding Rs. 50 lakh; fraudulently availing or attempting to avail drawback or exemption exceeding Rs. 50 lakh; and fraudulently obtaining an instrument under the Act or the Foreign Trade (Development and Regulation) Act, 1992 which is utilised, where the duty relatable exceeds Rs. 50 lakh. All other offences are non-cognizable, which means arrest requires a warrant.

Non-bailable, under Section 104(6): offences punishable under Section 135 relating to evasion or attempted evasion of duty exceeding Rs. 50 lakh; prohibited goods notified under Section 11 which are also notified under Section 135(1)(i)(C); import or export of undeclared goods with a market price exceeding Rs. 1 crore; fraudulent drawback or exemption exceeding Rs. 50 lakh; and fraudulently obtaining and utilising an instrument where the duty relatable exceeds Rs. 50 lakh. All other offences are bailable.

What the officer must now do

In Radhika Agarwal v. Union of India, decided on 27/02/2025, a three-judge Bench upheld the arrest provisions of the Customs Act, 1962 and Sections 69 and 70 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, held that reliance on Om Prakash v. Union of India was misconceived after the 2012, 2013 and 2019 amendments, and then set out what an arresting officer must do:

The offences themselves

VII. COFEPOSA: detention without a trial

What it is, and what it is not

The Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 is a preventive detention statute. It is not punishment for a past offence. It is executive confinement to prevent a future one, permitted by Article 22(3) to (7) of the Constitution, which expressly carves preventive detention out of the ordinary Article 22(1) and (2) protections.

Section 3(1) empowers the Central or a State Government, or a specially empowered officer, to detain a person with a view to preventing him from smuggling goods, abetting smuggling, engaging in transporting, concealing or keeping smuggled goods, dealing in smuggled goods otherwise, or harbouring persons engaged in smuggling.

Section 3(3) requires the grounds to be communicated to the detenu, ordinarily within five days and in exceptional circumstances, for reasons recorded, within 15 days, in discharge of the obligation under Article 22(5).

Section 8 constitutes Advisory Boards for the purposes of Article 22(4)(a) and 22(7)(c), headed by a person qualified to be a High Court judge, to which the case must be referred within five weeks, and clause (f) of which provides for confirmation.

Section 9 permits detention beyond three months without the Advisory Board's opinion, on a declaration made within five weeks by the Central Government or a specially empowered officer not below the rank of Additional Secretary, that the person smuggles, abets smuggling or deals in smuggled goods in an "area highly vulnerable to smuggling", which Explanation 1 defines by reference to specified Indian customs waters, an inland belt 50 km wide from the coast and from the India-Pakistan border, and specified customs airports and stations.

Section 10 sets the maximum period at one year where Section 9 does not apply and the order has been confirmed under Section 8(f), and two years where Section 9 applies. Section 11 provides for revocation, and Section 12 for temporary release.

There is no bail. So what is there?

There is no provision for bail under the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974, because there is no accusation, no charge and no trial. Bail attaches to a prosecution. Detention here is administrative. The remedies are of a different kind, and there are five:

The unsettled bit, stated honestly

In Additional Secretary to the Government of India v. Alka Subhash Gadia a three-judge Bench held, at paragraph 30, that a detention order may be challenged before execution only in narrow circumstances, listing five: that the order is not passed under the Act under which it purports to be passed; that it is sought to be executed against the wrong person; that it is passed for a wrong purpose; that it is passed on vague, extraneous or irrelevant grounds; and that the authority which passed it had no authority to do so.

Whether those five are exhaustive then divided the Court. In Sayed Taher Bawamiya v. Joint Secretary to the Government of India a three-judge Bench rejected the argument that they were merely illustrative. In Deepak Bajaj v. State of Maharashtra a two-judge Bench took the opposite view, reasoning that a judgment is not a statute. The point was settled the other way by a three-judge Bench in Subhash Popatlal Dave v. Union of India, (2012) 7 SCC 533, which held that a detention order may be challenged at the pre-execution stage on grounds beyond the five in paragraph 30.

A trap for the unwary: the later decision reported as Subhash Popatlal Dave v. Union of India, (2014) 1 SCC 280, is the same Bench deciding a different question, namely the position of a proposed detenu who has absconded or evaded execution and then seeks to challenge the order. The two reports are constantly confused. Cite (2012) 7 SCC 533 for the exhaustiveness point and (2014) 1 SCC 280 only for the absconder point, and cite Sayed Taher Bawamiya yourself and distinguish it rather than leaving it to the other side.

And the sting in the tail

A detention under the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 is the trigger for the Smugglers and Foreign Exchange Manipulators (Forfeiture of Property) Act, 1976, under which illegally acquired properties of a detenu and of specified relatives and associates may be forfeited. Clients frequently do not understand that the detention is not the end of the exposure.

VIII. Challenging the order

The ladder

The carve-out that catches practitioners out: under the first proviso to Section 129-A(1), no appeal lies to the Tribunal against an order of the Commissioner (Appeals) relating to (a) goods imported or exported as baggage, (b) short-landed goods, and (c) payment of drawback. For those three categories the remedy is a revision to the Central Government under Section 129-DD, within three months of communication, extendable by a further three, with a fee of Rs. 200 where the amount involved is Rs. 1 lakh or less and Rs. 1,000 where it is more.

This means the entire body of airport gold and jewellery litigation never reaches the Customs Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal. It goes to the Revisionary Authority, and from there to the High Court under Article 226.

On pre-deposit, Section 129-E requires, as a condition of entertaining the appeal, 7.5% before the Commissioner (Appeals), 7.5% before the Tribunal against an order of the Commissioner as adjudicating authority, and 10% before the Tribunal against an order of the Commissioner (Appeals), of the duty where duty or duty and penalty are in dispute, or of the penalty where only penalty is in dispute, subject to a ceiling of Rs. 10 crore. Section 129-EE provides interest on refund of the pre-deposit.

The department's own route

Section 129-D empowers the Committee of Chief Commissioners, or the Commissioner, to direct that an application be made to the Tribunal or the Commissioner (Appeals) for determination of points arising from an order it considers not legal or proper. Section 129-DD(1-A) allows the Commissioner to direct an application for revision on his own behalf. These matter to you for one reason: an order in your favour is not final until the Section 129-D window has closed. Section 129-DA, which older commentaries still cite as a revision power, has been omitted and confers nothing.

When to go straight to the High Court

An alternative remedy is a rule of discretion, not of jurisdiction. A writ under Article 226 is entertained where the order is without jurisdiction, in breach of natural justice, in violation of a fundamental right, or where the vires of a provision is challenged. Three fact patterns are almost always writ-worthy:

There is a further reason to prefer the writ in the airport cases. The statutory ladder for baggage runs from the Commissioner (Appeals) to a Central Government revision, and both are executive forums. Where the complaint is that the executive denied a hearing, sending the citizen back to the executive is not an efficacious remedy.

A word on "review"

There is no general power of review in the adjudicating authority. An officer who has passed an order in original is functus officio, subject only to rectification of a clerical or arithmetical error under Section 154. "Review" in customs vocabulary means the departmental review under Section 129-D, not review in the sense of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. Section 129-B(2) permits the Tribunal to rectify a mistake apparent from the record within the prescribed period. Review of a High Court judgment lies under Order XLVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 read with the High Court Rules, and of a Supreme Court judgment under Article 137.

IX. What the Constitution contributes

The Customs Act, 1962 is a fiscal statute and a police statute rolled into one, and Part III does real work in it.

Article 300A provides that no person shall be deprived of his property save by authority of law. Confiscation is a deprivation of property. It is authorised by law, so the enquiry is whether the law was followed. In Kolkata Municipal Corporation v. Bimal Kumar Shah the Supreme Court held that the minimum content of the right under Article 300A comprises seven sub-rights: notice, a hearing, a reasoned decision, acquisition only for a public purpose, restitution or fair compensation, an efficient and expeditious process, and a conclusion.

That case concerned compulsory acquisition, not confiscation, and it should not be over-read. But the reasoning, that "authority of law" under Article 300A carries an irreducible procedural minimum, transplants directly to a confiscation effected without notice, without hearing and without reasons. It is a submission worth making.

X. Compounding, and the exit that closed

The provision

Under Section 137(3), any offence under Chapter XVI may, either before or after the institution of prosecution, be compounded by the Chief Commissioner of Customs on payment of such compounding amount and in such manner as may be specified by rules.

When it is simply not available

The proviso to Section 137(3) excludes five categories:

The amounts

The Customs (Compounding of Offences) Rules, 2005, notified vide Notification No. 114/2005-Cus. (N.T.) dated 30/12/2005 and last amended vide Notification No. 69/2022-Cus. (N.T.) dated 22/08/2022, govern procedure. The compounding authority is the Principal Chief Commissioner or Chief Commissioner having jurisdiction; the reporting authority is the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner. Officers of customs are excluded from the definition of "applicant".

Where the same goods attract offences in more than one category on the same duty, drawback or market value, the higher amount applies.

Where the discretion lies

Rule 4 requires the compounding authority to call for a report from the reporting authority within one month, and then either to allow the application, indicating the amount and granting immunity under Rule 6, or to reject it. Two conditions are absolute:

The compounding amount must be paid within 30 days of receipt of the order, is not refundable except where the court refuses immunity, and Rule 4(7) states expressly that the applicant cannot claim as of right that his offence shall be compounded.

So the discretion sits in four places: whether to compound at all, which is quasi-judicial and must be exercised on the material in the report, after a hearing, with reasons; the quantum within the Rule 5 band, so that an order fixing the maximum without reasons is challengeable; the grant of immunity under Rule 6; and its withdrawal under Rule 7 for non-payment, breach of a condition, concealment or false evidence. What the authority does not have is discretion to compound in a case falling within the five statutory exclusions. Those are jurisdictional bars.

And the door that shut

Chapter XIV-A provided for settlement of duty cases before the Settlement Commission. That route is now closed prospectively. The Finance Act, 2025 inserted a proviso to Section 127-B(5) providing that no application shall be made on or after 01/04/2025, with pending applications passing to an Interim Board of three officers of Chief Commissioner rank or above, with no judicial member.

In any event, two exclusions always kept settlement out of reach in smuggling cases: no application could be made in relation to goods to which Section 123 applies, that is gold, manufactures of gold, watches and notified goods, or to goods in relation to which an offence under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 had been committed.

Which leaves a simple practical position. Compounding under Section 137(3) is now the only negotiated exit in a gold case, it has no equivalent Section 123 bar, and it closes the prosecution only. The confiscation, the redemption fine, the duty and the penalty still have to be fought, or paid.

XI. Does the present scheme work?

Three propositions, offered as argument rather than as settled law.

The enforcement design is broadly right and the enforcement practice frequently is not. A statute that reverses the burden of proof for gold, permits arrest on reason to believe, presumes culpable mental state and admits statements recorded by the seizing agency is a formidable instrument. That is defensible, because border offences are hard to detect and easy to deny. But the price of such an instrument is scrupulous procedure. When a Division Bench of the High Court has to direct the same department, repeatedly, to stop using a printed form to extinguish the right to a show cause notice and a hearing, the problem is not the statute. It is that the safeguards which justify the severity are being treated as optional.

The economic case is real but is usually stated badly. Smuggling is described as a loss of revenue. The revenue loss is the smallest part of it. The larger harms are that it destroys the price signal in the domestic market for the smuggled commodity, that it makes compliant importers uncompetitive against non-compliant ones, that it moves value through informal channels and so corrodes the formal financial system, and that it creates a permanent constituency with an interest in border corruption. Conversely, a great deal of smuggling is a rational response to a tariff or a restriction. The Act is a necessary instrument, but enforcement alone has never solved a smuggling problem created by a tariff wedge.

Four things are worth revisiting:

The counter-argument deserves to be stated. Every safeguard added at the border is a delay at the border, and an administration processing millions of passengers cannot function like a trial court. Those who defend the present design point out that the reversed burden under Section 123 applies only to a narrow notified list; that the arrest thresholds were deliberately raised in 2012, 2013 and 2019 to confine arrest to serious cases; that compounding, provisional release and settlement all existed precisely to provide off-ramps; and that the Supreme Court in Radhika Agarwal considered and rejected a full-frontal constitutional challenge to the arrest power while regulating its exercise. On that view the framework is already balanced, and what is needed is compliance, not amendment. Both positions are arguable, and the choice between them is a policy judgment on which reasonable people differ.

XII. The point

A border cannot work without self-declaration. No airport can physically examine every passenger. So the design is right: facilitate the many, and make the consequences of a false declaration serious.

But the severity is only defensible if the procedure is scrupulous. The Act itself supplies the procedure. Section 102 lets you demand a gazetted officer or a magistrate before a search. Section 80 protects the passenger who declares. Section 110 returns the goods if the notice does not come in six months. Section 124 guarantees a notice, a reply and a hearing. Section 125 caps the fine at market price. Section 153 tells you when you have been served. Radhika Agarwal tells the officer what he must write down before he arrests you.

Each of those is worth nothing to a person who does not know it exists at two in the morning, at a counter, with a form in front of him.

The green channel is not the problem. A system built on self-declaration works only if the consequences are imposed through a fair procedure.
Watch · The Office on YouTube

Two-minute explainers on the questions these essays raise.

The Office publishes short video versions of its long-form writing. Subscribe to be notified when the explainer for this article is released.

Sources and provisions referred to

Statutes and rules

Cases

Official documents

Frequently asked questions

I walked through the green channel and my gold chain was seized. What happens next?

Walking through the green channel is treated as a declaration that you carry nothing beyond the free allowance and nothing prohibited. If that is untrue the goods fall under Section 111(l) or Section 111(m) of the Customs Act, 1962 and become liable to confiscation, with penalty under Section 112. What should follow is a seizure under Section 110(1), a written show cause notice under Section 124, a written reply, a personal hearing and a reasoned order in original. For baggage, the appeal runs to the Commissioner (Appeals) and then to a revision before the Central Government, not to the Tribunal.

How long can customs keep my goods before issuing a notice?

Section 110(2) of the Customs Act, 1962 requires the goods to be returned if no notice under Section 124(a) is given within six months of seizure. The Principal Commissioner or Commissioner may extend that by a further six months for reasons recorded in writing, and must inform the person from whom the goods were seized before the original period expires. In Assistant Collector of Customs v. Charan Das Malhotra the Supreme Court held that this power is quasi-judicial, cannot be exercised mechanically, casts the burden on the department to show sufficient cause, and requires the person to be heard first.

The officer asked me to sign a printed form at the airport. What is it?

It is usually a pre-printed waiver of the written show cause notice and of the personal hearing, relying on the first proviso to Section 124 of the Customs Act, 1962, which permits notice and representation to be oral at the request of the person concerned. In Amit Kumar v. Commissioner of Customs a Division Bench of the Delhi High Court held that printed waivers fundamentally violate the rights of the persons affected, that any oral waiver must be a proper declaration consciously signed, that a hearing must still be afforded, and directed the department to discontinue the practice.

Can I get my goods back while the case is still going on?

Yes. Section 110-A of the Customs Act, 1962 allows goods, documents, things and provisionally attached bank accounts to be released to the owner pending the order of the adjudicating authority, on a bond in the proper form with such security and conditions as that authority may require. It is the most under-used remedy in customs practice. An application under Section 110-A, backed by a writ petition against an unreasoned refusal or an extortionate bond condition, will often achieve in weeks what the appellate route achieves in years.

When can a customs officer arrest me?

Under Section 104(1) of the Customs Act, 1962 an empowered officer who has reason to believe that a person has committed an offence under Section 132, 133, 135, 135-A or 136 may arrest him and must inform him of the grounds. In Radhika Agarwal v. Union of India, decided on 27/02/2025, the Supreme Court held that the reasons to believe must be recorded, must refer to the material and must show by computation how the monetary threshold is met, that arrest cannot be made merely to investigate whether the threshold is satisfied, and that the grounds of arrest must be given in writing before production before the magistrate.

These answers are educational summaries of the article above; they are not legal advice on any individual matter.

Corrections: if you find an error of law or fact in this article, write to contact@lokeshbhardwajlawoffices.com with the subject 'Correction'. Corrections are made in the text and noted here with the date.

Disclaimer

This article is published for general information and public legal education only. It does not constitute legal advice and does not create an advocate-client relationship. Every seizure, notice, order and detention turns on its own facts, documents and dates, and the law stated is as on the date of publication and is liable to change. Readers should obtain advice specific to their own facts before acting. Published in compliance with the Bar Council of India Rules, Chapter II, Part VI, Rule 36. No part of this article is intended to solicit professional engagement.

WhatsApp