Challenging Notifications, Rules and Circulars: Delegated Legislation in the Writ Courts
Most of the law that governs a business or a citizen day to day is not in an Act of Parliament but in the rules, regulations and notifications made under it, and in the circulars issued to apply them. Each of these can be tested in a constitutional court.
In brief
- What can be challenged. Rules, regulations, bye-laws and notifications made under an Act, and the circulars and instructions issued to apply them. Article 13(3)(a) of the Constitution counts a rule, regulation, notification and order having the force of law as "law", so each must respect the fundamental rights.
- The starting point. A rule is presumed valid, and the person who attacks it must show that it is invalid (State of Tamil Nadu v. P. Krishnamurthy, (2006) 4 SCC 517).
- The main grounds. The rule goes beyond the power the parent Act gives, conflicts with the Act or another statute, violates a fundamental right such as equality under Article 14, or is manifestly arbitrary. Excessive delegation is a challenge to the parent Act itself.
- Circulars. Executive instructions can fill gaps in statutory rules, but they cannot amend or supersede them (Sant Ram Sharma v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1967 SC 1910).
- No hearing before rules are made. Legislative action, plenary or subordinate, is not subject to the rules of natural justice unless the statute requires a hearing or consultation.
- Where. A writ petition in the High Court under Article 226, or in the Supreme Court under Article 32 where a fundamental right is in issue.
- Time. No fixed limitation period applies to a writ, but delay and laches can defeat a challenge, especially where others have acted on the rule.
- Interim relief. Because of the presumption of validity, a rule is rarely stayed as a whole at the interim stage; the court more often protects the petitioner alone, or makes action under the rule subject to the result.
Terms you will hear
- Delegated (subordinate) legislation
- Rules, regulations, bye-laws and notifications made by the Government or another body under a power given by an Act.
- Parent Act (enabling Act)
- The statute that confers the power to make the rule. The rule is valid only within that power.
- Ultra vires
- Beyond the power. A rule is ultra vires when it goes outside what the parent Act authorises, or conflicts with the Act or the Constitution.
- Notification
- A formal order or rule published in the Official Gazette, for example to bring a provision into force, fix a rate or grant an exemption.
- Circular or executive instruction
- A departmental direction on how a law is to be applied. It binds officers in the way it is framed but cannot override the Act or the statutory rules.
- Excessive delegation
- A challenge to the parent Act on the ground that the legislature handed over its essential legislative function without laying down a policy or guidance for the delegate.
- Manifest arbitrariness
- A ground of challenge under Article 14 where a rule is so unreasonable that the legislature cannot be taken to have authorised it.
- Reading down
- Giving a provision a narrower meaning so that it stays within the law, instead of striking it down.
- Severability
- Striking down only the invalid part of a rule where the rest can stand on its own.
In detail
This article is in 3 parts:
Challenges to notifications, rules and circulars
An Act of Parliament or a State legislature usually sets out the policy and leaves the detail to the Government or a regulator: the forms, the fees, the rates, the eligibility conditions, the dates on which provisions come into force. That detail is made through rules, regulations, bye-laws and notifications. Courts call it delegated or subordinate legislation, because the power to make it is delegated by the legislature and the instrument is subordinate to the Act.
Why the label of the document matters
The first task in any challenge is to identify exactly what kind of instrument is in issue, because it decides the questions the court will ask.
- Rules and regulations are made under an express rule-making section of the Act, usually published in the Gazette, and have the force of law.
- Notifications are published in the Gazette under a specific section that permits the Government to do something by notification: bring a provision into force, extend or exempt, fix a rate, specify an authority. A notification issued under the wrong section, or outside the conditions of the right one, is open to challenge.
- Circulars, office memoranda and instructions are executive directions. Executive instructions can fill gaps and supplement statutory rules where the rules are silent, but the Government cannot amend or supersede statutory rules by administrative instructions (Sant Ram Sharma v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1967 SC 1910). A circular that contradicts the Act or the rules is therefore open to challenge on that ground alone.
Because Article 13(3)(a) of the Constitution defines "law" to include any ordinance, order, bye-law, rule, regulation, notification, custom or usage having the force of law, delegated legislation must respect the fundamental rights in Part III in the same way as an Act.
Who can bring the challenge
The usual petitioner is a person whose business, property, service or liberty is affected by the rule, for example a licensee whose fee has been raised, an importer denied an exemption, a candidate excluded by a new eligibility condition, or an employee affected by a change in service rules. An association of the persons affected can also petition. Where the rule affects a section of the public who cannot approach the court themselves, a public interest petition may be possible (see the PIL page).
What the court can do
- declare the rule, notification or circular invalid, wholly or in part, and quash it;
- read it down so that it operates within the parent Act;
- quash the order or demand made under it against the petitioner;
- direct the authority to reconsider the matter in accordance with law;
- or uphold the rule and dismiss the petition.
A challenge can be framed against the rule itself, or against the way it has been applied to the petitioner. The second is often easier to win, and the relief is narrower.
Grounds: ultra vires, Article 14 and excessive delegation
The presumption of validity
The Supreme Court has held that there is a presumption in favour of the constitutionality or validity of subordinate legislation, and that the burden is on the person who attacks it to show that it is invalid (State of Tamil Nadu v. P. Krishnamurthy, (2006) 4 SCC 517). The petition must therefore show precisely which provision is said to be invalid and why, with the parent Act and the rule set side by side.
The recognised grounds
In the same case the Court listed the grounds on which subordinate legislation can be challenged:
- lack of legislative competence to make the subordinate legislation;
- violation of the fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution;
- violation of any other provision of the Constitution;
- failure to conform to the statute under which it is made, or exceeding the limits of the authority conferred by the enabling Act;
- repugnancy to the laws of the land, that is, to any enactment;
- manifest arbitrariness or unreasonableness, to an extent where the court might well say that the legislature never intended to give authority to make such a rule.
The Court drew this from the earlier ruling in Indian Express Newspapers (Bombay) Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, (1985) 1 SCC 641, which explained that subordinate legislation does not carry the same degree of immunity as a statute passed by a competent legislature: it may be questioned on any ground on which plenary legislation is questioned, and in addition on the ground that it does not conform to the statute under which it is made, or that it is contrary to some other statute.
Ultra vires the parent Act
This is the most common ground. It takes three main forms:
- No power. The rule deals with a matter the rule-making section does not cover, or imposes a fee, condition or penalty the Act does not authorise.
- Conflict with the Act. The rule contradicts a provision of the Act itself, or narrows a right the Act gives. A rule must give way to the Act.
- Procedure not followed. Where the Act requires the rule to be made only after previous publication, after consulting a named body, with the approval of an authority, or to be laid before the legislature, the petition examines whether that was done. Whether a lapse invalidates the rule depends on whether the requirement is mandatory under that Act.
Article 14 and manifest arbitrariness
Equality under Article 14 is tested in two ways. First, a rule that treats people differently must rest on a real difference between them that has a rational connection to the object of the rule. Second, a rule that is manifestly arbitrary or unreasonable can be struck down even without a comparison between classes, to the extent the Supreme Court described in State of Tamil Nadu v. P. Krishnamurthy, (2006) 4 SCC 517. Other fundamental rights are often engaged as well, most commonly the freedom to carry on any occupation, trade or business under Article 19(1)(g) and the right to life and personal liberty under Article 21.
Excessive delegation
Sometimes the problem is not that the rule exceeds the Act, but that the Act gives the delegate an unguided power: it lets the Government decide the policy itself, with no standard to apply. The legislature may delegate the detail, but not its essential legislative function of laying down the policy. A challenge on this ground is a challenge to the parent Act, so the petition must say so and the prayer must ask for the relevant section to be declared invalid. It is a heavier case to make than an ordinary ultra vires challenge, and it is usually pleaded together with it.
Grounds that do not usually succeed
- "I was not heard before the rule was made." Legislative action, plenary or subordinate, is not subject to the rules of natural justice, as the Supreme Court explained in Union of India v. Cynamide India Ltd., (1987) 2 SCC 720, a ruling applied in State of Tamil Nadu v. P. Krishnamurthy, (2006) 4 SCC 517. The position is different where the Act itself requires objections to be invited or a body to be consulted.
- "There is a better way to do this." The court asks whether the rule is within power and lawful, not whether it is the wisest policy.
- "The rule causes me hardship." Hardship alone does not invalidate a rule. It may support an argument that the rule is unreasonable to the point of being arbitrary, or that it has been wrongly applied.
A rule-making power ordinarily operates prospectively. A rule that takes effect from a past date, especially one that imposes a burden, is examined closely against the parent Act to see whether the Act permits it.
Procedure and interim relief
1. Before the petition: the record
- The instrument itself. Obtain the Gazette copy of the rule or notification (Central Government notifications are on the e-Gazette, egazette.gov.in) and every amendment, so that the version in force on the relevant date is known.
- The parent Act. The rule-making section, the section under which the notification issued, and any provision on previous publication, consultation or laying.
- The file. Where the reasons matter, an application under Section 6 of the Right to Information Act, 2005 for the file that led to the rule, including the notings and approvals, often supplies the material for the grounds. The RTI page explains the time limits and the appeals.
- The application to the petitioner. The demand, order, refusal or show cause notice issued under the rule, with the dates of receipt.
2. Choosing the forum
A challenge to the validity of delegated legislation is ordinarily brought in the High Court under Article 226. Under Article 226(2) a High Court may act where the cause of action arises wholly or in part within its territory, so a Central notification can be challenged in the High Court of Delhi or in the High Court where its effect is felt. Article 32 allows a direct petition to the Supreme Court where a fundamental right is in issue, but the Supreme Court often asks petitioners to go to the High Court first. Where a statute provides an appeal against orders made under the rule, the High Court usually expects that remedy to be used for a challenge to the order; the position is different where the validity of the rule itself is in question, which the appellate authority cannot decide. The writ jurisdiction explainer sets out how the alternative remedy rule works.
3. Drafting the petition
- the impugned rule, notification or circular, quoted and annexed, with the parent provisions;
- a list of dates showing when it was made, published and applied to the petitioner;
- the grounds, each tied to one of the recognised heads, with the comparison of rule and Act set out clearly;
- the prayer: a declaration that the provision is invalid, a writ quashing it and any order made under it, and consequential relief such as refund or reconsideration;
- the application for interim relief, stating the harm that waiting would cause;
- the authority that made the rule as respondent: the Union of India through the Ministry concerned, the State Government, or the regulator.
In the High Court of Delhi the petition is e-filed, scrutinised by the Registry for defects, and listed before the Bench assigned that category of work in the roster published by the Chief Justice.
4. Delay
No limitation period is written into Article 226, and the Limitation Act, 1963 does not apply to writ petitions in terms. A challenge brought long after a rule was made, after others have arranged their affairs on the basis of it, may still be refused for delay and laches. Where the rule is applied afresh to the petitioner, for example by a new demand, the application of the rule gives a fresh occasion to challenge it, but the delay in challenging the rule itself is still examined. The safe course is to file promptly and to explain any gap in the petition.
5. Interim relief
The presumption of validity weighs heavily at the interim stage. Courts are slow to suspend a rule or notification for everyone while its validity is examined. The interim orders more commonly made are narrower:
- an order protecting the petitioner alone from coercive action;
- an order that any action taken will be subject to the result of the petition;
- a deposit or security in place of payment of a disputed levy;
- an order preserving the position, for example keeping a seat or post vacant.
Where an interim order is made without the other side having been given copies of the petition and an opportunity of being heard, Article 226(3) allows that party to apply to have it vacated. The High Court is to dispose of the application within two weeks of receiving it, or of the petitioner being given a copy, whichever is later; if it does not, the interim order stands vacated.
6. Hearing, judgment and appeal
The respondent files a counter affidavit defending the rule, often with the reasons on the file, and the petitioner files a rejoinder. The matter is decided on the pleadings and documents. A judgment of a single judge of the High Court of Delhi in a writ may be carried in a Letters Patent Appeal to a Division Bench (see the Letters Patent Appeal explainer), and a judgment of a Division Bench by a special leave petition under Article 136 (see the SLP explainer).
Common mistakes
- Challenging the wrong instrument, for example the circular when the real problem is in the rule it applies, or the rule when the problem is in the Act.
- Relying on an unofficial copy of the rule instead of the Gazette text and its amendments.
- Pleading only hardship or unfairness, without tying the argument to a recognised ground.
- Asking for a stay of the rule for everyone when protection for the petitioner would meet the need.
- Waiting until the rule has been applied for years before challenging it.
Questions people ask
Can I challenge a government notification in court?
Yes. A notification, rule or regulation made under an Act can be challenged in a writ petition in the High Court under Article 226, or in the Supreme Court under Article 32 where a fundamental right is in issue. The usual grounds are that it goes beyond the power the parent Act gives, conflicts with the Act or another statute, violates a fundamental right such as equality under Article 14, or is manifestly arbitrary. The court starts from a presumption that the notification is valid, so the petition must show exactly which provision is invalid and why, with the parent Act and the notification compared side by side.
What is the difference between a rule and a circular?
A rule is made under an express rule-making power in an Act and has the force of law. A circular or office memorandum is an executive direction telling officers how to apply the law. The Supreme Court has held that executive instructions can fill gaps in statutory rules where the rules are silent, but cannot amend or supersede them. So a circular that contradicts the Act or the rules can be challenged on that ground, while a rule can only be challenged on the grounds that apply to delegated legislation, such as being beyond the power of the parent Act.
What does ultra vires mean?
Ultra vires means beyond the power. A rule or notification is ultra vires when it deals with something the parent Act does not authorise, imposes a condition, fee or penalty the Act does not permit, contradicts a provision of the Act, or was made without following a mandatory procedure the Act lays down, such as previous publication or consultation. A rule can also be invalid because it violates the Constitution, which is sometimes described as being ultra vires the Constitution. If the court agrees, it can strike down the provision, wholly or in part, or read it down so that it stays within the Act.
Is there a time limit to challenge a rule or notification?
No fixed period applies to a writ petition, and the Limitation Act, 1963 does not apply to writs in terms. But the High Court can refuse relief for delay and laches. It looks at how long the petitioner waited, whether the delay is explained, and whether others have acted on the rule in the meantime. A fresh application of the rule to the petitioner, such as a new demand, gives a fresh occasion to challenge it, but the court will still consider why the rule itself was not challenged earlier. The safe course is to file promptly and explain any gap in the petition.
Can a notification be stayed while the case is pending?
It can, but a stay of a rule or notification for everyone is uncommon, because the court starts from a presumption that delegated legislation is valid. The interim orders more usually made are narrower: protection for the petitioner alone from coercive steps, an order that any action taken will abide by the result of the petition, a deposit or security in place of payment, or an order keeping a post or seat vacant. The application must show why waiting for the final hearing would cause harm that cannot be undone, and why the balance of convenience favours the petitioner.
Did the government have to hear me before making the rule?
Usually not. The Supreme Court has held that legislative action, whether by the legislature or by a delegate making rules, is not subject to the rules of natural justice. The position changes where the parent Act itself requires a draft to be published for objections, or a named body to be consulted, before the rule is made. In that case the petition can examine whether the procedure was followed, and whether the requirement was mandatory. A decision applying the rule to a particular person, as opposed to the making of the rule, is a different matter and ordinarily does require a fair hearing.
Should I go to the High Court or the Supreme Court?
Usually the High Court. Article 226 is wider than Article 32: it covers statutory and other legal rights as well as fundamental rights, and under Article 226(2) a petition can be filed where the cause of action arises wholly or in part. Article 32 is available only to enforce a fundamental right, and the Supreme Court frequently asks petitioners to approach the High Court first. A High Court judgment also leaves an appeal open, by a Letters Patent Appeal within the High Court where available and then by a special leave petition to the Supreme Court.
Can a circular override an Act or the rules?
No. A circular is an executive instruction. It cannot amend or supersede the Act or the statutory rules made under it. Where the rules are silent on a point, the Government can issue instructions to fill the gap, provided they are consistent with the rules. A demand or refusal based on a circular that contradicts the Act or the rules can be challenged in a writ, and often the simplest relief is to quash the order made under the circular, without striking down the circular for everyone.
What happens if the court strikes down a rule?
The provision ceases to operate, and orders made under it against the petitioner are usually quashed with it. The court may strike down only the invalid part, where the rest can stand on its own, or read the provision down so that it operates within the parent Act. The judgment may also direct consequential relief, such as a refund or a fresh decision. The Government can appeal, and it can also make a fresh rule that cures the defect, provided it stays within the power the Act gives.
Can a trade or professional association file the challenge?
Yes, an association of the persons affected by a rule can petition, and it is common for a challenge to a fee, licensing condition or regulatory notification to be brought by an association together with one or more of its members. The association should show that the rule affects its members, that it is authorised by its governing body to file, and the facts of at least one member to whom the rule has been applied. Including an affected member as a co-petitioner avoids an argument about standing.
These answers are educational summaries; they are not legal advice on any individual matter.
A serious question deserves a read brief.
Conferences are by appointment at G-46, Basement, Greater Kailash III, New Delhi. The principal reads the correspondence.
This page gives general information about the work of Lokesh Bhardwaj Law Offices, as permitted under the Bar Council of India Rules. It is not legal advice, and it does not create an advocate-client relationship. LBLO acts in a matter only on an engagement agreed in writing.
Law stated as at 16/11/2026.
← All Practice Areas