Civil Appeals, Review and Revision: RFA, RSA, FAO and Letters Patent Appeals in Delhi
A party who loses a civil case usually has one full appeal on facts and law, a narrower second appeal on a substantial question of law, and separate remedies against orders made during the case: review, revision and, within the High Court, the Letters Patent Appeal.
In brief
- First appeal (RFA in the High Court). An appeal lies from every decree passed by a court of original jurisdiction (Section 96, CPC). It is a rehearing on facts and law, and the appellate court must give its own reasons on each point (Order XLI Rule 31).
- Where it goes in Delhi. An appeal from a Civil Judge's decree goes to the District Judge; an appeal from a decree of a District Judge or Additional District Judge in a suit they tried goes to the High Court as a regular first appeal (Sections 38 and 39, Punjab Courts Act, 1918, as applied to Delhi).
- Second appeal (RSA). An appeal from a decree passed in first appeal lies to the High Court only if the case involves a substantial question of law, which must be stated in the memorandum and formulated by the court (Section 100).
- Appeals from orders (FAO). Only the orders listed in Section 104 and Order XLIII Rule 1 can be appealed, such as orders on temporary injunctions, receivers, return of a plaint, and refusal to set aside an ex parte decree.
- Review and revision. A review asks the same court to correct an error apparent on the face of the record or to consider new evidence that could not be produced earlier (Order XLVII). A revision asks the High Court to correct a jurisdictional error of a subordinate court where no appeal lies (Section 115).
- Time limits. Thirty days for an appeal to the District Judge, ninety days for an appeal to the High Court, thirty days for an appeal within the High Court and for a review, ninety days for a revision, and sixty days for a commercial appeal. Delay can be condoned for sufficient cause, which must be shown.
Terms you will hear
- RFA and RFA(OS)
- a regular first appeal under Section 96 to the High Court, from a decree of a district court (RFA) or, within the High Court, from a decree of a single judge on the Original Side (RFA(OS)).
- RSA
- a regular second appeal to the High Court under Section 100, on a substantial question of law.
- FAO and FAO(OS)
- a first appeal from an order, under Section 104 and Order XLIII, or under a statute that provides an appeal from an order.
- Substantial question of law
- a question of law, debatable and material to the outcome, on which a second appeal must be founded.
- Review
- an application to the court that decided the matter to reconsider its decision on the limited grounds in Order XLVII Rule 1.
- Revision
- the High Court's power under Section 115 to correct a subordinate court's error of jurisdiction in a case where no appeal lies.
- CM(M)
- the name used in the High Court of Delhi for a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution against an order of a civil court.
- LPA
- a Letters Patent Appeal: an appeal within the High Court from the judgment of a single judge to a Division Bench.
In detail
The Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) gives the right of appeal, the Limitation Act, 1963 the time, and the Punjab Courts Act, 1918, as applied to Delhi, the forum for appeals from the district courts. The High Court of Delhi tries suits of a value above Rs. 2 crore on its Original Side; a 2026 proposal to raise that limit needs an amendment by Parliament. In outline:
- Civil Judge's decree: first appeal (a regular civil appeal) to the District Judge, who may assign it to an Additional District Judge (Section 39); in very small suits, such as money suits up to Rs. 1,000, a High Court notification of 11/08/2000 sends the appeal to the Senior Civil Judge;
- decree of a District Judge or Additional District Judge in a suit it tried: RFA in the High Court (Section 38);
- decree passed in first appeal by a subordinate court: RSA in the High Court;
- decree or appealable order of a single judge on the Original Side: RFA(OS) or FAO(OS) to a Division Bench; commercial appeals carry a "(COMM)" suffix, for example RFA(OS)(COMM);
- judgment of the High Court: special leave petition to the Supreme Court under Article 136.
Appeals in civil cases: RFA, RSA and FAO
1. The first appeal
An appeal lies from every decree passed by a court of original jurisdiction unless a law provides otherwise, including an ex parte decree, but not a consent decree (Section 96(1) to (3)). In small-cause type suits up to Rs. 10,000 it lies only on a question of law (Section 96(4)). A preliminary decree, such as one declaring shares in a partition suit, must be appealed when made; it cannot be questioned in an appeal from the final decree (Section 97).
The memorandum of appeal, with a copy of the judgment, sets out the grounds concisely, under distinct heads and without argument or narrative (Order XLI Rule 1). Against a money decree the appellant must, within the time the court allows, deposit the amount disputed or furnish security (Rule 1(3)). A respondent may file a cross-objection within one month of service of notice of the appeal (Rule 22).
2. What the first appellate court does
The court may dismiss the appeal after hearing the appellant at admission, a hearing to be concluded as far as possible within sixty days of filing (Order XLI Rules 11 and 11A). If admitted, the appeal is a rehearing on facts and law, and the judgment must state the points for determination, the decision and reasons on each, and the relief (Rule 31). The court may decide the suit finally, remand it, or pass any decree that ought to have been passed (Rules 23 to 25 and 33). Additional evidence is allowed only where the trial court wrongly refused it, where it could not be produced despite due diligence, or where the appellate court requires it, with reasons recorded (Rule 27).
3. Stay of the decree
An appeal does not by itself stay the decree. The appellate court may stay execution only if substantial loss may otherwise result, the application was made without unreasonable delay, and security is given (Order XLI Rule 5(1) and (3)); without the deposit or security required for a money decree, it shall not stay execution (Rule 5(5)).
4. The second appeal
A second appeal lies only if the High Court is satisfied that the case involves a substantial question of law, which the memorandum must state precisely and the court formulates; the appeal is heard on that question, though the court may, for recorded reasons, hear it on another (Section 100). No second appeal lies on other grounds (Section 101), or where the original suit was for recovery of money not exceeding Rs. 25,000 (Section 102). Findings of fact of the first appellate court are ordinarily final.
5. The Registry's checks in the High Court of Delhi
The High Court's published list of common objections asks, for an RFA or RSA, for a caveat report, a memo of parties showing each party's status in the trial court, security charges of Rs. 100, court fee according to valuation, certified copies of the judgment and decree, a statement of how the appeal is maintainable, the substantial questions of law in the grounds, and a list of dates and synopsis. For an FAO it asks how the appeal is maintainable against an order that may be revisable rather than appealable.
Miscellaneous appeals against orders (Order XLIII)
1. Only listed orders are appealable
An appeal lies from the orders listed in Section 104 and, under that section, from the orders listed in Order XLIII Rule 1, and save as otherwise expressly provided, from no other orders (Section 104(1)). Order XLIII Rule 1 includes orders:
- returning a plaint to the proper court (Order VII Rule 10);
- rejecting an application to set aside a dismissal for default or an ex parte decree (Order IX Rules 9 and 13);
- setting aside or refusing to set aside a sale in execution (Order XXI Rules 72 and 92);
- refusing to set aside an abatement (Order XXII Rule 9);
- for attachment before judgment (Order XXXVIII Rules 2, 3 and 6);
- granting or refusing temporary injunctions, including on disobedience (Order XXXIX Rules 1, 2, 2A, 4 and 10);
- appointing a receiver (Order XL Rules 1 and 4);
- remanding a case, or refusing to re-admit or re-hear an appeal (Order XLI Rules 19, 21, 23 and 23A);
- granting a review (Order XLVII Rule 4).
2. No further appeal, and orders that are not appealable
No appeal lies from an order passed in such an appeal (Section 104(2)), and Order XLI applies to its procedure (Order XLIII Rule 2). A non-appealable order may be questioned in the appeal against the decree (Order XLIII Rule 1A) and, depending on the order, by revision or under Article 227. Other statutes give their own appeals against orders, such as motor accident and matrimonial appeals, registered under separate case types.
3. Commercial suits
In a commercial dispute, an appeal lies from an order of a Commercial Court or Commercial Division only if the order is specifically enumerated in Order XLIII, as amended by the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, or falls under Section 37 of the Arbitration Act (proviso to Section 13(1A)). No revision lies against an interlocutory order of a Commercial Court (Section 8).
Review and revision
1. Review
A person aggrieved by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed but has not been filed, or from which no appeal is allowed, may apply to the court that passed it for a review (Section 114 and Order XLVII Rule 1). The grounds are:
- the discovery of new and important matter or evidence that, after the exercise of due diligence, was not within the applicant's knowledge or could not be produced when the decree or order was made;
- some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record;
- any other sufficient reason.
A later decision of a superior court on the point of law is not a ground (Explanation to Rule 1). The judge who decided the matter ordinarily hears the review (Rule 5); notice must issue before a review is granted, and new evidence needs strict proof (Rule 4(2)). An order rejecting a review is not appealable, but one granting it may be challenged (Rule 7; Order XLIII Rule 1(w)), and no review lies against an order on a review (Rule 9). The period is thirty days (Article 124). A review is not a disguised appeal.
2. Revision under Section 115
The High Court may call for the record of a case decided by a subordinate court in which no appeal lies to the High Court, and interfere if the subordinate court appears to have exercised a jurisdiction not vested in it, failed to exercise a jurisdiction vested in it, or acted illegally or with material irregularity in exercising it (Section 115(1)). Since 01/07/2002 the High Court may not vary or reverse an order made in the course of a suit unless the order, had it been made in favour of the party applying for revision, would have finally disposed of the suit or proceeding (proviso to Section 115(1)). No revision lies against a decree or order against which an appeal lies to the High Court or a subordinate court (Section 115(2)), and a revision does not stay the suit unless the High Court orders a stay (Section 115(3)). The period is ninety days from the decree or order (Article 131).
3. Article 227
Because the proviso to Section 115 shuts out revision against most interlocutory orders, such orders are commonly challenged in the High Court of Delhi under Article 227 of the Constitution, by a petition registered as CM(M). The jurisdiction is supervisory, not a further appeal on every error of fact or law. Rent control revisions are registered separately as RC.REV.
Letters Patent Appeals
Within the High Court of Delhi, a judgment of a single judge can in many cases be taken to a Division Bench of two judges. In writ matters this is done by a Letters Patent Appeal; where the single judge was exercising ordinary original civil jurisdiction, as in a suit on the Original Side, the appeal lies under the Delhi High Court Act, 1966. The appeal lies only against a "judgment", meaning a decision that finally decides the matter or affects valuable rights, not a routine procedural order.
Three limits are checked first:
- Section 100A of the CPC: where an appeal from an original or appellate decree or order is heard and decided by a single judge of the High Court, no further appeal lies from that judgment, notwithstanding anything in the Letters Patent. So there is no LPA against a single judge's judgment in an RFA, RSA or FAO from the district courts.
- Article 227: where the single judge exercised supervisory jurisdiction over a court, no intra-court appeal lies, whatever the label on the petition.
- Commercial matters: appeals are governed by Section 13 of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, which allows an appeal from an order only where the order is one it lists, regardless of the Letters Patent.
The period is thirty days from the judgment (Article 117). The Registry asks for the complete record before the single judge, a certificate that all of it has been filed, and a statement of how the LPA is maintainable. The tests of maintainability are explained in the Office's explainer on Letters Patent Appeals in Delhi.
Limitation and condonation of delay
1. The periods
- Appeal under the CPC to a court other than the High Court, such as the District Judge: thirty days from the date of the decree or order (Article 116(b)).
- Appeal under the CPC to the High Court, including an RFA, RSA or FAO: ninety days from the date of the decree or order (Article 116(a)).
- Appeal from a decree or order of the High Court to the same court, including an LPA: thirty days (Article 117).
- Commercial appeal: sixty days from the judgment or order (Section 13(1A), Commercial Courts Act, 2015).
- Review of judgment by a court other than the Supreme Court: thirty days from the date of the decree or order (Article 124).
- Revision under the CPC: ninety days from the date of the decree or order (Article 131).
- Restoring an appeal, review or revision dismissed for default: thirty days from the dismissal (Article 122); re-hearing an appeal heard ex parte: thirty days (Article 123).
2. Counting
The time needed to obtain a copy of the judgment and decree is excluded under Section 12 of the Limitation Act, which is why certified copies are endorsed with the dates of application, preparation and delivery. Worked examples are on the Office's Limitation Act page.
3. Condonation
An appeal filed late must be accompanied by an application supported by an affidavit setting out the facts relied on as sufficient cause (Order XLI Rule 3A(1)). Notice issues to the respondent and the delay is decided before the appeal is heard, and no stay of execution is granted until the court decides to hear the appeal (Order XLI Rule 3A(2) and (3)). Delay in re-filing an appeal returned by the Registry for defects needs its own explanation.
In Pathapati Subba Reddy (Died) by LRs v. Special Deputy Collector (LA), 2024 INSC 286, decided on 08/04/2024, the Supreme Court summarised the principles: Section 5 is construed liberally but Section 3 strictly; a liberal or justice-oriented approach cannot be used to defeat the law of limitation; condonation is discretionary and may be refused even where some cause is shown, for inordinate delay, negligence or want of due diligence; relief given to others in similar matters is not by itself a ground; and the merits of the appeal are not considered while deciding whether to condone delay. In commercial appeals, delay beyond the sixty days is condoned only by way of exception, for a short delay by a party that acted in good faith and without negligence.
4. Common mistakes
- Filing an FAO against an order not in Order XLIII, or an LPA against a single judge's judgment in an appeal from a district court.
- Using the ninety-day period for an appeal to the District Judge, or the general periods for a commercial appeal.
- Seeking a stay of a money decree without the deposit or security Order XLI requires.
LBLO first identifies the remedy and forum, computes the last date from the certified copy, and then drafts the grounds from the trial court record.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between an RFA, an RSA and an FAO?
An RFA is a regular first appeal to the High Court against a decree, under Section 96 of the CPC; it reopens facts and law. An RSA is a regular second appeal to the High Court against a decree passed in first appeal, and lies only on a substantial question of law under Section 100. An FAO is a first appeal from an order, available only against the orders listed in Section 104 and Order XLIII Rule 1, or under a statute that allows an appeal from an order.
How many days do I have to file a first appeal in the Delhi High Court?
Ninety days from the date of the decree under Article 116(a) of the Limitation Act, 1963, for an appeal under the CPC to the High Court. An appeal to the District Judge from a Civil Judge's decree has thirty days (Article 116(b)). In a commercial dispute of specified value, the period is sixty days under Section 13(1A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. The time spent obtaining a certified copy of the judgment and decree, if applied for, is excluded under Section 12 of the Limitation Act.
Does filing an appeal stop the decree from being executed?
No. Under Order XLI Rule 5(1), an appeal does not operate as a stay, and execution is not stayed merely because an appeal has been filed. The appellant must apply for a stay. The court grants it only if substantial loss may result without it, the application is made without unreasonable delay and security is given (Rule 5(3)). For a money decree, the appellant must deposit the amount disputed or give security as directed, and without that the court shall not stay execution (Rules 1(3) and 5(5)).
Can I file a second appeal on facts?
Generally no. Section 100 of the CPC allows a second appeal only if the High Court is satisfied that the case involves a substantial question of law, which the memorandum must state precisely and which the court formulates before hearing the appeal. Findings of fact by the first appellate court are ordinarily final. A second appeal also does not lie where the original suit was for recovery of money not exceeding Rs. 25,000 (Section 102).
Which orders of a civil court can be appealed?
Only those listed in Section 104 and Order XLIII Rule 1 of the CPC, or made appealable by another statute. They include orders returning a plaint, refusing to set aside a dismissal for default or an ex parte decree, granting or refusing temporary injunctions, attachment before judgment, appointing receivers, setting aside or refusing to set aside execution sales, remanding a case and granting a review. Other orders can be questioned in the appeal against the final decree (Order XLIII Rule 1A), or in some cases by revision or a petition under Article 227.
What is the difference between a review and a revision?
A review is filed in the same court that decided the matter, within thirty days (Article 124), on the grounds in Order XLVII Rule 1: new and important evidence that could not be produced earlier despite due diligence, an error apparent on the face of the record, or another sufficient reason. A revision is filed in the High Court under Section 115, within ninety days (Article 131), against a subordinate court's decision in a case where no appeal lies, on grounds of jurisdiction, illegality or material irregularity.
Can I file an LPA against a single judge's decision in a first or second appeal?
No. Section 100A of the CPC provides that where an appeal from an original or appellate decree or order is heard and decided by a single judge of a High Court, no further appeal lies from that judgment, notwithstanding the Letters Patent. The next remedy is a special leave petition to the Supreme Court under Article 136. An LPA is used mainly against judgments of single judges in writ petitions under Article 226, and an appeal to a Division Bench also lies from Original Side decrees.
My appeal is late. Can the delay be condoned?
Yes, if sufficient cause is shown, under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963. File an application supported by an affidavit setting out the facts that explain the delay, with the appeal (Order XLI Rule 3A). The court decides the delay first, after notice to the other side. The Supreme Court has said that sufficient cause is a condition precedent, that condonation is discretionary and may be refused for inordinate delay, negligence or want of diligence, and that the merits are not considered at that stage (Pathapati Subba Reddy (Died) by LRs v. Special Deputy Collector (LA), 2024 INSC 286).
Can new evidence be produced in an appeal?
Only in the cases Order XLI Rule 27 allows: where the trial court refused to admit evidence it should have admitted; where the party shows that despite due diligence the evidence was not within its knowledge or could not be produced when the decree was passed; or where the appellate court itself requires a document or witness to pronounce judgment or for another substantial cause. The court must record its reasons for admitting the evidence.
Do I have to deposit the decree amount to file an appeal?
The appeal can be filed without a deposit, but where the decree is for payment of money, Order XLI Rule 1(3) requires the appellant, within the time the appellate court allows, to deposit the amount disputed in the appeal or furnish such security as the court thinks fit. If the deposit or security is not made, Order XLI Rule 5(5) prevents the court from staying execution of the decree.
My appeal was dismissed because no one appeared. What can I do?
Apply to the appellate court for re-admission of the appeal under Order XLI Rule 19, showing that you were prevented by sufficient cause from appearing. The period is thirty days from the date of dismissal (Article 122, Limitation Act, 1963). If the court is satisfied, it must re-admit the appeal on terms as to costs or otherwise. A respondent against whom an appeal was heard ex parte can similarly apply for a re-hearing under Order XLI Rule 21.
These answers are educational summaries; they are not legal advice on any individual matter.
A serious question deserves a read brief.
Conferences are by appointment at G-46, Basement, Greater Kailash III, New Delhi. The principal reads the correspondence.
This page gives general information about the work of Lokesh Bhardwaj Law Offices, as permitted under the Bar Council of India Rules. It is not legal advice, and it does not create an advocate-client relationship. LBLO acts in a matter only on an engagement agreed in writing.
Last reviewed: 16/11/2026. Lokesh Bhardwaj Law Offices.
Law stated as at 16/11/2026.
← All Practice Areas