Commercial leasing, clause by clause
A negotiation and risk note for landlords and occupiers, from the first recital to the last reinstatement.
A residential letting is a short bargain over a flat. A commercial or industrial lease is a long-dated capital commitment on both sides. The landlord is financing a building against a rent roll. The occupier is sinking fit-out capital, moving people, obtaining licences, and in an industrial case installing plant that cannot be moved. Neither side can walk away cheaply, and that asymmetry drives every clause.
I. How a commercial lease differs, and why it matters
Five structural differences shape the drafting:
- Rent control is almost always irrelevant. In Delhi, Section 3(c) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 excludes any premises, residential or not, whose monthly rent exceeds Rs. 3,500. Every real commercial letting is therefore governed by the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 and by the contract. The contract is the law between the parties. There is no statutory safety net.
- Terms are long, so registration is compulsory, not optional. Any term exceeding one year requires a registered instrument. There is no eleven month workaround for a nine year anchor lease.
- Force majeure is a drafted allocation of risk, not a statutory right. Indian law will not imply rent abatement into a lease. If the clause does not say it, it does not happen.
- The Commercial Courts Act, 2015 may govern the dispute, which brings pre-institution mediation, case management and time-bound procedure into play.
- Industrial premises carry regulatory and environmental liabilities that survive the lease. These are frequently the largest exposure in the deal and are almost never negotiated properly.
II. Lease, licence, and why large occupiers should not accept a licence
2.1 The legal distinction
Lease: Section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 defines this as a transfer of a right to enjoy immovable property for a certain time in consideration of a price paid or promised. It creates an interest in the land, and the lessee is entitled under Section 108 of that Act to be put in possession, to the exclusion of the lessor.
Licence: Section 52 of the Indian Easements Act, 1882 defines this as a right to do something in or upon the immovable property of the grantor which would otherwise be unlawful, where the right does not amount to an easement or an interest in the property.
The operative difference is possession. In a lease, legal possession passes to the lessee. In a licence, legal possession remains with the grantor and the licensee has bare permission to use. A licensee cannot sue a stranger in trespass in his own right; a lessee can.
2.2 The test
In Associated Hotels of India Ltd. v. R.N. Kapoor, the Supreme Court laid down the key principles:
- Substance is preferred to form.
- The real test is the intention of the parties.
- If the document creates an interest in the property it is a lease; if it only permits use, legal possession remaining with the owner, it is a licence.
- Exclusive possession makes the occupant prima facie a tenant, though circumstances may negative that intention.
- The Court also held that a right to transfer the interest, even with the grantor's consent, is destructive of any theory of licence.
2.3 What follows for a commercial deal
Here is how common arrangements are correctly classified:
- Managed office or co-working seat, with provider-controlled access and no demarcated demise: yes, this is a genuine licence. The provider retains possession and services.
- Kiosk or shop-in-shop within a department store: usually a licence. Watch for exclusive control of the demarcated area.
- Retail concession with revenue share: doubtful to be a licence if the concessionaire fits out and controls the space. The substance is likely a lease.
- ATM or telecom tower site with the operator's own locked enclosure: usually a lease of the enclosure, though frequently mis-labelled as a licence.
- Warehouse, factory shed, or a full floor of office space with the occupier's own access control: a lease, whatever the heading. Calling it a licence achieves nothing.
- Signage or hoarding rights on a facade: a licence, as there is no possession of the structure.
Advice to a large occupier: do not accept a "leave and licence" for premises you will fit out, staff, and hold for years. You are paying lease consideration for licence security. A licence is revocable under the Indian Easements Act, 1882. Compensation is not a substitute for a plant you cannot relocate.
Advice to a landlord: if you genuinely want a revocable arrangement, structure it as one in fact, not merely in the recitals. Retain access, retain services, do not permit fit-out, do not permit assignment, and do not hand over sole keys.
III. Registration and stamping: non-negotiable for any real term
3.1 The rule
Section 107 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 requires that a lease of immovable property from year to year, or for any term exceeding one year, or reserving a yearly rent, can be made only by a registered instrument. Section 49 of the Registration Act, 1908 renders an unregistered instrument inadmissible as evidence of any transaction affecting the property.
3.2 What non-registration destroys in a commercial deal
The Supreme Court has repeatedly held, in Anthony v. K.C. Ittoop & Sons, Park Street Properties and Paul Rubber Industries, that an unregistered document cannot be looked into to prove the terms of the lease. What survives is merely a month to month tenancy.
Translate that into commercial consequences:
- The agreed term: for the occupier, a 15 year lease becomes month to month, terminable on 15 days' notice, leaving fit-out capital stranded. For the landlord, the rent roll evaporates, and the asset cannot be financed or valued on the lease.
- Lock-in: the occupier cannot hold the landlord to the term, and the landlord cannot hold the occupier to the term.
- Escalation: the landlord cannot enforce the agreed increase.
- Renewal option: becomes entirely worthless.
- Permitted use and exclusivity: the occupier cannot enforce these against the landlord, and the landlord cannot enforce restrictions on the occupier.
- Assignment restrictions: the landlord loses control over who occupies the premises.
- The manufacturing purpose: the occupier loses the six month notice period protection under Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
3.3 Stamp duty
Practical points that recur in large deals:
- The rate rises with the term. A 30 year lease can attract duty approaching conveyance rates in several states. Model the duty before fixing the term.
- Escalation and premium: where rent escalates, duty is generally computed on the average annual rent across the term. Any premium is separately chargeable.
- Security deposit: a refundable deposit returnable on determination has been held not separately chargeable in Delhi, but an interest-free deposit that is in substance consideration may be treated differently.
- Who pays: Section 29 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 places the duty on a lease on the lessee in the absence of agreement. Say so in the draft.
- Consequence of under-stamping: inadmissibility and impounding, with penalty recoverable by the Collector.
IV. Due diligence: what an occupier must establish before committing
4.1 Title and authority
Check the full chain of title, not merely the latest deed. Ensure the board resolution or partnership authority for the signatory is valid. Where the property is co-owned, all co-owners must execute.
4.2 The leasehold land trap
Industrial and institutional plots are commonly held on perpetual lease from a state authority. Such leases almost always restrict sub-letting, change of activity, or shareholding transfers.
An occupier taking such premises without the authority's permission may find the head lease determined and its own sub-lease falling with it. Obtain the authority's written permission and annex it. This is the single most commonly skipped diligence step in industrial leasing.
4.3 Building and use compliance
Verify sanctioned plans, completion and occupancy certificates. Confirm the permitted land use under the applicable Master Plan. Check for the fire no objection certificate, the lift licence and structural stability certificates. Insist on a measured floor plan and a stated loading factor, so that super area and carpet area can be correctly calculated.
4.4 For industrial premises specifically
Check the factory licence, the consent to establish and the consent to operate under the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 and the Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981, environmental clearances, effluent treatment guidelines, and legacy contamination. Establish the site's prior use and insist on a baseline environmental site assessment before possession.
V. The three risks occupiers under-price
5.1 The landlord's mortgage
If the property is mortgaged, the occupier's position under enforcement is fragile. Search for charges through the Central Registry of Securitisation Asset Reconstruction and Security Interest of India. If the property is mortgaged, obtain the lender's written consent to the lease and a non-disturbance agreement.
5.2 Sale, transfer and attornment
A registered lease binds a purchaser. An unregistered arrangement leaves the occupier renegotiating with a stranger. Provide expressly for the occupier's attornment to any transferee and for the transfer of the security deposit.
5.3 Insolvency of either party
If the landlord enters insolvency, an occupier with a registered lease is in a materially better position than one without. Draft for an event of default on insolvency, and seek a security package that does not depend purely on the occupier's solvency.
VI. Cost allocation: the commercial position
Section 108 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 supplies defaults in the absence of contract. In institutional leasing those defaults are always displaced. What follows reflects the position this office regards as market-standard and defensible. Anything marked negotiable is where deals are actually won and lost.
- Stamp duty and registration: ordinarily the occupier, or shared. State it expressly, as the statutory default is on the lessee.
- Property tax and municipal rates: ordinarily the landlord. The occupier should resist a pass-through of increases; if conceded, cap the annual increase.
- Ground rent to the development authority: ordinarily the landlord. On leasehold land this is the head-lessee's obligation.
- Common area maintenance: ordinarily the occupier. Negotiate hard. Require an audited, itemised statement, an annual cap on escalation, exclusion of capital expenditure, and audit rights.
- Capital replacement of common plant such as lifts, chillers and diesel generating sets: ordinarily the landlord. This is the most common common area maintenance abuse; exclude it expressly.
- Structural repairs, roof, facade, waterproofing, columns: ordinarily the landlord. Include a self-help and set-off right if the landlord defaults after notice.
- Repairs within the demised premises: ordinarily the occupier.
- Fit-out and interiors: ordinarily the occupier. The landlord may contribute a fit-out allowance, documented as a rent-free period or a reimbursement against certified bills.
- Base build shortfalls: ordinarily the landlord. Annex a specification of the warm shell or bare shell condition to be delivered.
- Electricity, water and gas consumption: ordinarily the occupier. Require separate metering, not apportionment.
- Sanctioned load enhancement: ordinarily the occupier, where it is for its own requirement. The load reverts at exit.
- Backup generation capacity: negotiable. Fix the rate in Rs. per kVA and the availability commitment.
- Insurance of the structure: ordinarily the landlord.
- Insurance of contents, plant and public liability: ordinarily the occupier. Require the landlord to be named as additional insured for public liability.
- Fire and life safety compliance of the base building: ordinarily the landlord.
- Fire and life safety compliance of the fit-out: ordinarily the occupier.
- Environmental consents and compliance for the occupier's activity: ordinarily the occupier.
- Pre-existing contamination: ordinarily the landlord. Non-negotiable for the occupier. Demand a baseline assessment plus an indemnity.
- Brokerage: practice varies.
- Goods and services tax on rent: the occupier bears it.
- Tax deducted at source: the occupier deducts it.
VII. The clauses that decide the deal
7.1 Term, lock-in and exit
Fix the commencement date by reference to a defined event, such as handover of the premises, and not to a calendar date. In institutional leases the lock-in should be mutual and symmetrical. A lock-in binding only the occupier is a one-way option in the landlord's favour and should be resisted.
7.2 Rent, escalation and review
Fixed escalation on stated anniversaries is the Indian norm. If a revenue share applies, define gross revenue precisely, exclude goods and services tax and returns, and provide for audit rights.
7.3 Security
A security deposit of three to twelve months is common. A bank guarantee is preferable to a cash deposit for a landlord dealing with a thinly capitalised occupier. Address the refund mechanism strictly: simultaneous with handover, against a joint inspection, with a closed list of permitted deductions supported by invoices.
7.4 Assignment, sub-letting and change of control
Landlords prefer no assignment without prior written consent, and a change in control deemed an assignment. Occupiers should seek a free right to assign to an affiliate on notice without consent, carving out intra-group reorganisations.
7.5 Permitted use, exclusivity and quiet enjoyment
Define permitted use widely enough to accommodate the occupier's business plan, but narrowly enough for the landlord to protect the asset. Draft an express quiet enjoyment covenant.
7.6 Alterations, fit-out and reinstatement
Reinstatement at exit is where large sums are lost. State precisely what must be removed and what may remain, and take photographs of the delivered condition. A blanket obligation to restore "to original condition" on a bare shell handed over eight years earlier is unworkable.
7.7 Default, cure and forfeiture
Separate monetary from non-monetary default, with different cure periods. Landlords should note that self-help, such as sealing the premises or cutting off power, is unlawful and exposes the landlord to a suit under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963.
VIII. Force majeure: the clause that large occupiers must get right
This is the section to read twice. Indian law does not give a commercial tenant rent relief. The clause does, or nothing does.
8.1 The framework
The Supreme Court in Energy Watchdog clarified that force majeure relatable to an express clause is governed by Section 32 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. Rising input costs are commercial hardship, not force majeure.
8.2 Section 56 does not apply to leases at all
The Delhi High Court in Ramanand v. Dr. Girish Soni held that a lease is a completed conveyance, an executed contract and not an executory one. Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 cannot be invoked to claim waiver or suspension of rent.
8.3 Section 108(B)(e) is not a commercial remedy
Invoking Section 108(B)(e) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 presupposes that the property has been destroyed or rendered substantially and permanently unfit. Temporary inability to use the premises, including under a government order, does not qualify.
8.4 Drafting a force majeure clause for a large commercial or industrial lease
- Definition: an inclusive list plus a catch-all.
- Express exclusions: state that force majeure does not include lack of funds, market downturn, or increase in input costs.
- The consequence, stated expressly: choose one and write it down, whether rent abates in full, rent abates proportionately, rent is deferred, or rent continues but the lock-in is suspended.
- A defined trigger threshold: tie it to a stated reduction in usable area or to consecutive days prevented.
- Mitigation: an express obligation to mitigate.
- Duration and termination: if the event continues beyond a stated period, commonly 90 to 180 days, either party may terminate.
- Industrial-specific: address failure of the common effluent treatment plant or suspension of a consent to operate.
IX. Tax
9.1 Goods and services tax
Renting of commercial immovable property is a supply of service taxable at 18 per cent. State whether rent is inclusive or exclusive of goods and services tax, require a valid tax invoice carrying the landlord's registration number, and address the reverse charge position where the landlord is unregistered.
9.2 Tax deducted at source
Section 194-I of the Income-tax Act, 1961 mandates deduction for rent exceeding Rs. 6,00,000 per financial year, with effect from 01/04/2025. Where a lease has a plant and machinery component, split the consideration in the deed so that the correct rate applies to each limb.
X. Dispute resolution and procedure
10.1 Arbitration is available
Following Vidya Drolia v. Durga Trading Corporation, landlord and tenant disputes governed by the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 are arbitrable. Draft the arbitration clause properly: the number of arbitrators, the appointment mechanism, the seat, and the governing law.
10.2 The Commercial Courts Act, 2015
Whether a lease dispute is a commercial dispute turns on Section 2(1)(c)(vii) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. Where the dispute is of a specified value, pre-institution mediation under Section 12A is mandatory unless urgent interim relief is genuinely contemplated.
XI. An industrial lease checklist, separately
Industrial leases fail in ways office leases do not. In addition to everything above:
- Permitted activity: defined by reference to the specific manufacturing process, because consents attach to the process.
- Consents and licences: clearly define who applies, who holds and who renews.
- Baseline environmental site assessment: conducted before possession, jointly commissioned, with an indemnity from the landlord for pre-existing contamination.
- Hazardous substances: disclosure, storage limits, and compliance rules.
- Effluent and emissions: connection to the common effluent treatment plant and allocated capacity.
- Power and structural loading: sanctioned load, high tension metering, floor load-bearing capacity certified for the plant, and crane and gantry rights.
- Plant and machinery: a schedule identifying each item, the right to remove at exit, and an express statement that the occupier's plant does not become a fixture.
- Reinstatement: define the scope precisely, or agree a fixed sum. Address foundations, pits, bunds and services.
- Labour: the occupier's registrations, and an indemnity against claims by workmen and contract labour.
Two-minute explainers on the questions these essays raise.
The Office publishes short video versions of its long-form writing. Subscribe to be notified when the explainer for this article is released.
Sources and provisions referred to
Statutes and rules
- Transfer of Property Act, 1882: Sections 105, 106, 107, 108 and 108(B)(e)
- Indian Easements Act, 1882: Section 52
- Registration Act, 1908: Section 49
- Indian Stamp Act, 1899: Section 29
- Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958: Section 3(c)
- Indian Contract Act, 1872: Sections 32, 56 and 74
- Specific Relief Act, 1963: Section 6
- Commercial Courts Act, 2015: Sections 2(1)(c)(vii) and 12A
- Income-tax Act, 1961: Section 194-I
- Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974
- Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981
Cases
- Associated Hotels of India Ltd. v. R.N. Kapoor
- Anthony v. K.C. Ittoop & Sons
- Park Street Properties
- Paul Rubber Industries
- Energy Watchdog
- Ramanand v. Dr. Girish Soni, Delhi High Court
- Vidya Drolia v. Durga Trading Corporation
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a lease and a leave and licence?
A lease under Section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 transfers a right to enjoy the premises for a term and passes legal possession to the lessee, who is entitled to exclude the lessor. A licence under Section 52 of the Indian Easements Act, 1882 is bare permission to use, legal possession remaining with the grantor. In Associated Hotels of India Ltd. v. R.N. Kapoor the Supreme Court held that substance prevails over form, that intention is the real test, and that exclusive possession makes the occupant prima facie a tenant. Heading a document a licence does not make it one.
Is a lock-in period enforceable against a tenant?
A lock-in in a duly registered lease is ordinarily enforceable as a contractual bargain, but the remedy is money, not compulsion to occupy. A landlord cannot force a tenant to remain in physical occupation; on early exit he may claim the rent for the unexpired lock-in, subject to the duty to mitigate and to Section 74 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 where the stipulated sum is in the nature of a penalty. A lock-in in an unregistered lease of more than one year is unenforceable, because the instrument cannot be looked into to prove the term.
Must a commercial lease be registered?
Yes, wherever the term exceeds one year, or the lease is from year to year, or it reserves a yearly rent. Section 107 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 requires a registered instrument, and Section 49 of the Registration Act, 1908 makes an unregistered instrument inadmissible as evidence of the transaction. The Supreme Court has held that such a document cannot be looked into to prove the terms of the lease; what survives is a month to month tenancy. Term, lock-in, escalation, renewal and assignment restrictions all fall away. There is no eleven month workaround for a nine year lease.
Can the landlord forfeit the security deposit?
Only to the extent the lease permits and the loss is proved. A deposit is held against defined contingencies, principally unpaid rent, utility arrears, damage beyond fair wear and tear, and agreed reinstatement. It is not a windfall, and a forfeiture clause operating as a penalty attracts Section 74 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, under which only reasonable compensation is recoverable. An occupier should insist on a closed list of permitted deductions supported by invoices, refund simultaneous with handover against a joint inspection, and a stipulated rate of interest for delay in refund.
What happens if the tenant does not vacate at the end of the term?
The tenancy determines and the occupier holds over as a tenant at sufferance, liable to pay mesne profits or damages for use and occupation, at the enhanced rate stated in the lease if one is stated. The landlord's remedy is a suit for possession, and where the lease so provides, arbitration, which is available for such disputes following Vidya Drolia v. Durga Trading Corporation. Self-help is unlawful: sealing the premises or cutting off power exposes the landlord to a suit under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 for restoration of possession.
These answers are educational summaries of the article above; they are not legal advice on any individual matter.
Corrections: if you find an error of law or fact in this article, write to contact@lokeshbhardwajlawoffices.com with the subject 'Correction'. Corrections are made in the text and noted here with the date.
This article is published for general information and public legal education only. It does not constitute legal advice and does not create an advocate-client relationship. Every commercial lease turns on its own facts and documents, and the law stated is as on the date of publication and is liable to change. Readers should obtain advice specific to their own facts before acting. Published in compliance with the Bar Council of India Rules, Chapter II, Part VI, Rule 36. No part of this article is intended to solicit professional engagement.
← Articles