Associations, Societies, Trusts and Institutions
For the bodies through which people organise themselves: associations, societies, trusts, schools and temples.
Lokesh Bhardwaj Law Offices (LBLO) acts for bodies as well as for individuals. Its work includes trade associations, bar and professional associations, resident welfare associations, registered societies and cooperative societies, schools, and temples and religious trusts.
A collective body has problems an individual does not: whether it is properly constituted, who may speak and sue for it, whether its last election was valid, and how far it can bind its members. The Office advises on the constitution and governance of such bodies, and represents them, or their members, when those questions become disputes.
Much of this work is preventive: memoranda, rules and trust deeds drafted so that elections, accounts and succession to office do not end in litigation. When disputes do arise, they may lie before the Registrar of Societies, the Registrar of Cooperative Societies and the Delhi Cooperative Tribunal, the civil court, or the High Court in its writ jurisdiction, and the Office considers the forum at the outset. LBLO also acts for associations in writ proceedings against regulators, utilities and civic bodies where a grievance is common to their members.
What the Office takes on
- Societies: Registration, Rules and Amendments
- Private Trusts: Deeds, Trustees and Succession
- Governing Body Elections and Disputes
- Proceedings before the Registrar of Societies
- Resident Welfare Associations: Maintenance and Common Areas
- Apartment Owners' Associations under the 1986 Act
- Cooperative Societies: Registrar and Tribunal
- Writs on behalf of Associations
- Representations for Trade and Professional Bodies
- Schools and Educational Societies
- Temples, Religious Trusts and Endowments
- Public Trust Suits under Section 92, CPC
How the work is conducted
The Office begins with the body's own documents: the memorandum and rules or bye-laws, the trust deed, the registration certificate, the minutes and resolutions, the list of members and the annual filings. Most disputes about collective bodies are decided on these papers, and many are decided by whether the body followed its own rules. The second question is authority: who has been authorised, by which resolution, to give instructions, to sign the pleadings and to bind the body. For associations seeking relief against a regulator or utility, the Office identifies the members affected and the common grievance, so that the association's standing to sue on their behalf is clear on the record. Opinions and representations to government for trade and professional bodies are prepared on the governing statute and the departmental record, and are written so that they can be relied on later if the matter goes to court.
Frequently asked questions
How is a society registered, and what does it have to file every year?
Under Section 1 of the Societies Registration Act, 1860, any seven or more persons associated for a literary, scientific or charitable purpose, or a purpose listed in Section 20, may form a society by subscribing to a memorandum of association and filing it with the Registrar. Section 2 requires the memorandum to state the name, the objects and the members of the governing body, and a copy of the rules certified by at least three members of the governing body must be filed with it. Section 4 then requires a list of the governing body to be filed with the Registrar once every year, after the annual general meeting.
The election of our society's governing body is disputed. Where is that decided?
The Societies Registration Act, 1860 makes the Registrar principally an authority of registration and record: the Registrar receives the memorandum, the rules and the annual list of the governing body under Section 4. A contested election, or a dispute over who validly holds office, is therefore ordinarily decided by the civil court in a suit for declaration and injunction, tested against the society's own rules. Under Section 6, a society sues and is sued in the name of its president, chairman, principal secretary or trustees, as its rules provide. Where the society is a cooperative society, the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act, 2003 provides a separate route.
Can our RWA charge maintenance and control parking in the common areas?
It depends on the law that governs the building. Where the Delhi Apartment Ownership Act, 1986 applies, Section 15 requires an association of apartment owners to administer the building and manage its common areas under bye-laws based on the model bye-laws notified by the Administrator, and Section 3(j) defines common areas and facilities to include parking areas. Where the Act does not apply, the RWA's powers come from its own constitution, usually as a society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, and from the conveyance deeds of the flats. A charge or parking rule must be traceable to one of these sources and adopted by the procedure they prescribe.
How are disputes in a cooperative housing society in Delhi resolved?
Under Section 70 of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act, 2003, disputes touching the constitution, management or business of a cooperative society, including disputes between a member and the society or its committee, are referred to the Registrar of Cooperative Societies. The Registrar decides whether the dispute falls within the provision and, if it does, it goes to arbitration under Section 71; election disputes have been treated as falling within this route. A decision under Section 70 may be appealed to the Delhi Cooperative Tribunal under Section 112. Some questions, such as membership, fall under other provisions of the Act, and choosing the wrong provision can lead to dismissal on a technical ground.
Can an association file a writ petition on behalf of its members?
Generally, yes. A registered association may approach the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India where a decision of a regulator, utility or public authority affects its members in a common way, and the members are identifiable. The court will ask whether the grievance is genuinely common to the members, rather than personal to a few of them, and whether the association has resolved to bring the case and authorised the person signing it. The right to form associations is itself guaranteed by Article 19(1)(c). A writ is not ordinarily available where the dispute is private, such as one between the association and a single member.
Is a temple or religious trust governed by the Indian Trusts Act, 1882?
No. Section 1 of the Indian Trusts Act, 1882 provides that the Act does not apply to public or private religious or charitable endowments, so a temple endowment is governed by its deed, custom and the general law. For public trusts of a charitable or religious nature, Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 allows the Advocate General, or two or more persons having an interest in the trust, to sue for relief such as removal of a trustee or a scheme of administration, with the leave of the court. Article 26 of the Constitution protects a religious denomination's right to manage its own affairs in matters of religion and to administer its property in accordance with law.
Should a new institution be set up as a trust, a society or a company?
Each has a different structure. A private trust under the Indian Trusts Act, 1882 is controlled by its trustees, and under Section 5 a trust of immovable property must be declared by a registered non-testamentary instrument or by will. A society under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 is governed by its members through a governing body, and changes are deliberately difficult: under Section 12, altering its purposes needs three-fifths of the members at a special meeting, confirmed at a second meeting a month later, and under Section 13 dissolution needs three-fifths of the members. A not-for-profit company may be formed under Section 8 of the Companies Act, 2013, with corporate governance obligations.
Can a trade association advise its members on prices or make collective decisions about trade?
A trade association may lawfully represent its members to government, publish information, and seek opinions on the law that governs its trade. It must, however, keep away from collective commercial decisions. Under Section 3(3) of the Competition Act, 2002, a decision taken by an association of enterprises that directly or indirectly determines prices, limits supply or shares markets is presumed to have an appreciable adverse effect on competition, and such decisions are void under Section 3(2). A circular fixing rates, or a call to boycott a supplier, can therefore expose the association and its office-bearers to proceedings before the Competition Commission of India.
These answers are educational summaries; they are not legal advice on any individual matter.
A serious question deserves a read brief.
Conferences are by appointment at G-46, Basement, Greater Kailash III, New Delhi. The principal reads the correspondence.
← All Practice Areas