Protecting what you built.
An educational note on how brands, inventions and technical knowledge are protected in India, how far that protection travels, and what it takes to keep it alive.
Most businesses own more intellectual property than they realise, and protect less of it than they assume. A name on a signboard, a formulation, a machine modified on the shop floor, a customer list, a piece of software, a moulded shape: each of these may be a valuable asset, and each is protected, if at all, by a different body of law, with different requirements and different deadlines.
I. Why this matters before it matters
Intellectual property is also the rare asset that is usually cheapest to secure at the very moment nobody is thinking about it, and most expensive to recover once somebody else has taken it.
The purpose of this note is to set out the map: what the categories are, how a mark or an invention is actually protected, how far that protection travels, and what a business must do to keep it.
This note is educational and general. It is not legal advice, and no reader should act on it without advice on the specific facts.
II. The families of intellectual property in India
India protects intellectual property through separate statutes, each with its own subject matter, its own registry and its own life span:
- Trade marks: the Trade Marks Act, 1999, read with the Trade Marks Rules, 2017. Protects the signs that tell a buyer whose goods or services these are.
- Patents: the Patents Act, 1970, read with the Patents Rules, 2003 as amended. Protects inventions.
- Copyright: the Copyright Act, 1957. Protects original literary, dramatic, musical and artistic works, films and sound recordings. Software is protected as a literary work. Registration is optional, though useful in evidence.
- Designs: the Designs Act, 2000. Protects the shape, configuration, pattern or ornamentation applied to an article and judged solely by the eye.
- Geographical indications: the Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999.
- Plant varieties: the Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmers' Rights Act, 2001.
- Semiconductor layouts: the Semiconductor Integrated Circuits Layout-Design Act, 2000.
- Trade secrets and know-how: no dedicated statute. Protected through contract, the equitable duty of confidence and the general law.
Two consequences follow. First, a single product usually attracts several rights at once: the invention inside it, the shape outside it, the brand on it, the manual with it and the process behind it. Second, these rights do not overlap neatly. What is refused as a patent may still be held as a trade secret. What is refused as a trade mark may still be defended in passing off.
III. Trade marks
3.1 What a trade mark is
Section 2(1)(zb) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 defines a trade mark as a mark capable of being represented graphically and capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one person from those of others. Section 2(1)(m) tells us what a mark can be: a device, brand, heading, label, ticket, name, signature, word, letter, numeral, shape of goods, packaging or combination of colours.
The operative word is distinguishing. A trade mark is not a decoration and not a description. It is a badge of origin. A sign that does not tell the buyer who stands behind the goods is not doing the job the statute exists to protect, and the Registry will say so.
3.2 The kinds of marks
- Word marks: the name alone, in any font. The broadest and usually the most valuable form of protection.
- Device or logo marks: the visual mark as drawn.
- Composite marks: word and device together. Note Section 17: registration of a composite mark as a whole does not confer an exclusive right in a part of it that would not have been registrable on its own.
- Shape marks and packaging or trade dress: subject to the shape exclusions in Section 9(3).
- Combination of colour marks: a single colour is difficult; a defined combination is easier.
- Sound marks: for which the Trade Marks Rules, 2017 expressly provide a filing mechanism.
- Certification trade marks: under Section 2(1)(e) and Chapter VIII, marks that certify origin, material, method of manufacture, quality or accuracy. The proprietor certifies and does not trade in the goods.
- Collective marks: under Section 2(1)(g), marks distinguishing the goods of members of an association.
- Series marks: under Section 15, where several marks resemble each other in material particulars and differ only in non-distinctive matter.
- Well-known marks: under Section 2(1)(zg), discussed below.
- Unregistered marks: there is no infringement action for an unregistered mark, but Section 27(2) preserves the action for passing off.
3.3 Classes, and how to identify them
India follows the NICE Classification of goods and services, reproduced in the Fourth Schedule to the Trade Marks Rules, 2017. There are 45 classes: Classes 1 to 34 cover goods and Classes 35 to 45 cover services.
Class selection is not a clerical step. It draws the boundary of the monopoly. A registration in Class 25 for garments does not, by itself, give exclusivity over the same word for hotel services in Class 43. The right question is not "which class does my product sound like", but "what does the business actually sell today, and what will it sell in the next three to five years". The answer is then filed for, either as separate single-class applications or as one multi-class application.
3.4 What is registrable and what is not
Section 9 sets out the absolute grounds for refusal. A mark is refused if it is devoid of distinctive character; if it consists exclusively of indications designating the kind, quality, quantity, intended purpose, values, geographical origin or time of production of the goods; if it consists exclusively of marks or indications that have become customary in the current language or in the bona fide and established practices of the trade; if it deceives the public or causes confusion; if it contains scandalous or obscene matter or matter likely to hurt religious susceptibilities; if its use is prohibited under the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act, 1950; or if it consists exclusively of a shape resulting from the nature of the goods, a shape necessary to obtain a technical result, or a shape giving substantial value to the goods.
The proviso to Section 9(1) is the escape route: a mark is not refused on those grounds if, before the date of application, it has in fact acquired a distinctive character as a result of use, or is a well-known mark. This is proved, not asserted: dated invoices, advertising spend, turnover, geographical spread, length and continuity of use, press coverage and, where available, survey evidence.
Section 11 sets out the relative grounds: conflict with an earlier mark, where identity or similarity of the marks and of the goods or services creates a likelihood of confusion, including a likelihood of association.
3.5 Your own name, and ordinary words
A personal name or surname enjoys no special privilege. It is registrable only if it is distinctive, or has become distinctive through use. A common surname used in the trade will meet resistance.
Two provisions deserve attention. Section 14 requires consent where the mark falsely suggests a connection with a living person, or with a person who has recently died, in the circumstances the section describes. Section 35 works the other way: it protects the bona fide use by a person of his own name, or the name of his place of business, or a bona fide description of the character or quality of the goods. A registration therefore does not automatically silence an honest competitor who happens to share the name.
Generic and descriptive words are the most common cause of refusal and of weak rights. "Fresh" for juice, "Quick" for a delivery service, "Gold" for jewellery: each describes rather than distinguishes. Invented words, arbitrary words and suggestive words are cheaper to register, cheaper to enforce and cheaper to defend. The money saved on branding creativity is usually spent later on evidence of acquired distinctiveness.
3.6 First use or first filing
Both matter, and the interaction is the single most misunderstood point in Indian trade mark practice.
Registration confers the exclusive right to use the mark for the registered goods or services and the right to sue for infringement (Section 28), and the register is prima facie evidence of validity (Section 31). But Section 34 saves vested rights: a registered proprietor cannot interfere with a mark that another person has used continuously from a date earlier than the proprietor's use of the mark, or the date of the proprietor's registration, whichever is earlier.
In practice, the prior user with dated documents often prevails over the later registrant. The lesson is not to skip registration; it is to keep the evidence. The first invoice, the first advertisement, the first dated packaging artwork, the first purchase order for labels: these are the documents that decide such disputes years later.
3.7 Passing off, which is where unregistered marks live
Passing off is the common law action against misrepresentation of trade origin, preserved by Section 27(2). It rests on three elements: goodwill or reputation attached to the goods or services; a misrepresentation by the defendant, whether or not intentional, leading or likely to lead the public to believe that the defendant's goods or services are those of the claimant; and damage or the likelihood of damage.
In Toyota Jidosha Kabushiki Kaisha v. Prius Auto Industries Ltd., decided on 14/12/2017, the Supreme Court applied the territoriality principle in preference to the universality doctrine. Reputation earned abroad is not, by itself, enough. The claimant must establish goodwill within India at the relevant date.
The practical reading of that decision is not that transborder reputation is dead. It is that transborder reputation must be proved as spillover into India, through Indian circulation of foreign media, Indian advertising, Indian enquiries, Indian trade presence and Indian consumer awareness, at a date earlier than the defendant's adoption. Assertion will not do.
3.8 The Registry, and the steps to registration
The Trade Marks Registry functions under the Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks, with the head office at Mumbai and offices at Delhi, Kolkata, Chennai and Ahmedabad.
- Search: a public search of the Registry's database across the relevant classes, plus a common law search of the market, corporate names and domain names. Search first, adopt second, spend on branding third.
- Application: on Form TM-A, stating the mark, the applicant, the classes, the specification of goods or services, and whether the mark is proposed to be used or is already in use, with the date of first use. A claimed user date must be capable of proof.
- Formalities check: then examination against the absolute grounds in Section 9 and the relative grounds in Section 11. The examination report sets out the objections.
- Reply: to the examination report, with evidence of use where distinctiveness is in issue, followed by a show cause hearing if the Registrar is not satisfied.
- Acceptance: and advertisement in the Trade Marks Journal.
- Opposition: any person may oppose within four months from the date of advertisement (Section 21). The applicant must file a counterstatement within two months of receiving the notice, failing which the application is deemed abandoned. Evidence follows, then a hearing and a decision.
- Registration: and issue of the certificate under Section 23, with effect from the date of the application.
3.9 Keeping the mark alive
- Term and renewal: registration lasts 10 years and is renewable for successive periods of 10 years (Section 25). A renewal missed is a right at risk; restoration is possible but is neither automatic nor free.
- Non-use: under Section 47 a registration may be taken off the register where the mark has not been used in relation to the registered goods or services for a continuous period of five years and three months, subject to the exceptions in the section. A defensive registration that is never used is vulnerable.
- Rectification: Section 57 allows removal or variation of an entry wrongly made or wrongly remaining on the register.
- Use the mark as registered: sustained departure from the registered form weakens the registration and the evidence built on it.
3.10 Well-known marks
A well-known mark, defined in Section 2(1)(zg), is protected beyond the goods or services for which it is registered. Section 11(6) lists the factors the Registrar must consider, including knowledge in the relevant section of the public, duration and extent of use and promotion, and the record of successful enforcement. Sections 11(7) to 11(9) elaborate, and make clear that use or registration in India is not a precondition to a mark being treated as well known.
Rule 124 of the Trade Marks Rules, 2017 provides a direct route: the proprietor may apply to the Registrar for determination of a mark as well known, on payment of the prescribed fee and with supporting evidence, and the Registry maintains a published list of such marks.
3.11 Preventing others from using the mark
- Civil suit: infringement is defined in Section 29, which covers identical and similar marks, use in advertising, and use of a mark as part of a trade name. Section 135 provides for injunction, damages or account of profits and delivery up. Section 134 permits a suit where the plaintiff carries on business, which is a significant practical advantage.
- Commercial Courts Act, 2015: applies to intellectual property suits above the specified value, with pre-institution mediation subject to the exception for suits contemplating urgent interim relief.
- The Delhi High Court Intellectual Property Rights Division Rules, 2022: and the corresponding rules of other High Courts, which have created dedicated intellectual property benches following the abolition of the Intellectual Property Appellate Board by the Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021.
- Criminal remedies: under Chapter XII of the Act for falsifying and falsely applying marks, and for selling goods bearing a false mark.
- Customs recordal: under the Intellectual Property Rights (Imported Goods) Enforcement Rules, 2007, which allows suspension of clearance of infringing imports.
- Domain names: through the INDRP for .in domains and the UDRP for generic top level domains, in addition to a suit.
- Administrative vigilance: a watch service on the Journal, opposition filed within the four month window, and prompt objection to company and LLP names.
Practical experience suggests that the cheapest enforcement is early enforcement. Rights that are policed consistently are easier to defend; rights that are ignored for years invite arguments of acquiescence under Section 33 and of delay.
IV. Crossing borders: what travels and what does not
4.1 The rule
Intellectual property rights are territorial. An Indian registration is an Indian right. It is not automatically honoured abroad, and a foreign registration is not automatically honoured in India. There is no world trade mark and no world patent. What the international system provides is not a global right but a set of shared procedures, shared priority rules and shared minimum standards.
4.2 A foreign registered mark in India
A proprietor who holds registrations in 30 countries but not in India has no infringement action in India. Four routes exist:
- Register in India: which is the only complete answer.
- Claim convention priority: under the reciprocal arrangements given effect by Section 154 of the Act, an application filed in India within six months of the first application in a convention country is treated as made on the date of that earlier application. The Paris Convention allows six months for marks and industrial designs, and 12 months for patents.
- Sue in passing off: if goodwill in India can be proved, subject to what the Supreme Court held in the Prius case.
- Assert well-known status: under Sections 11(6) to 11(9), which reflect Article 6bis of the Paris Convention and do not require Indian use or registration.
4.3 An Indian registered mark abroad
An Indian registration is not honoured abroad. Protection must be sought where the business sells, where it manufactures, and where counterfeits of its goods are made, which is often a different list from where it earns.
Two routes are available. The first is direct national filing in each country, using convention priority where the six month window is still open. The second is the Madrid Protocol, to which India has been a party since 08/07/2013. Under Madrid, an Indian applicant uses its Indian application or registration as the basic mark, files a single international application through the Indian office as office of origin, and designates the contracting parties in which protection is sought.
Madrid delivers one application, one language, one fee stream, one renewal date and one place to record assignments and address changes. It does not deliver a single right. Each designation is examined by that country's office under its own law and may be refused there, in which case local counsel and a local response are required. For the first five years the international registration is dependent on the basic mark, so a successful attack on the Indian mark can bring down the whole international registration, a risk usually described as central attack.
4.4 The treaties India has joined
The following are the principal intellectual property treaties to which India is a party, with the date each entered into force for India:
- Convention establishing WIPO: 01/05/1975
- Berne Convention (copyright): 01/04/1928
- Paris Convention (industrial property): 07/12/1998
- Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT): 07/12/1998
- TRIPS Agreement (WTO): 01/01/1995
- Budapest Treaty (deposit of microorganisms): 17/12/2001
- Madrid Protocol (international registration of marks): 08/07/2013
- Marrakesh Treaty (accessible formats): 30/09/2016
- WIPO Copyright Treaty and WPPT: 25/12/2018
- Nice, Vienna and Locarno Agreements (classification): 07/09/2019
- Strasbourg Agreement (patent classification): 07/07/2026
It is equally important to know what India has not joined. India is not a party to the Hague Agreement on the international registration of industrial designs, so designs must still be filed country by country. India is also not a party to the Rome Convention, the Singapore Treaty on the Law of Trademarks, the Patent Law Treaty or the UPOV Convention, plant varieties being protected instead under India's own 2001 Act.
V. Patents
5.1 The bargain
A patent is a bargain with the State. In exchange for a full and enabling disclosure of the invention, the patentee receives the exclusive right to make, use, sell, offer for sale and import the invention for a term of 20 years from the date of filing (Section 53).
When the term ends the disclosure belongs to everyone. That is the point of the system, and it explains most of the rules.
Three requirements must be met. The invention must be new, in the sense of not anticipated by publication or use anywhere in the world; it must involve an inventive step, defined in Section 2(1)(ja) as a feature involving technical advance or economic significance or both, that makes the invention not obvious to a person skilled in the art; and it must be capable of industrial application. It must also not fall within the exclusions.
5.2 What cannot be patented
Section 3 excludes, among other things: frivolous inventions and those contrary to natural laws; inventions contrary to public order or morality or seriously prejudicial to human, animal or plant life or health or to the environment; the mere discovery of a scientific principle or of a living thing occurring in nature; mere admixtures; mere arrangements or rearrangements of known devices; methods of agriculture or horticulture; any process for the medicinal, surgical, curative or other treatment of human beings or animals (Section 3(i)); plants and animals in whole or in part; mathematical or business methods, computer programmes per se and algorithms (Section 3(k)); literary, dramatic, musical or artistic works; presentation of information; topography of integrated circuits; and traditional knowledge. Section 4 bars inventions relating to atomic energy.
The most litigated of these is Section 3(d), which denies patentability to the mere discovery of a new form of a known substance that does not result in the enhancement of the known efficacy of that substance. In Novartis AG v. Union of India, decided on 01/04/2013, the Supreme Court held that in the case of medicines efficacy under Section 3(d) means therapeutic efficacy, and that improved physical properties and improved bioavailability, without evidence of improved therapeutic effect, do not satisfy the test. The provision is the statutory answer to what is commonly called evergreening.
For software, medical devices and instruments this section is where most applications are won or lost. A claim drafted to a technical effect achieved by hardware and software working together is treated differently from a claim drafted to a programme as such. The drafting decision is made at the beginning and cannot easily be repaired later.
5.3 The steps to a patent
- Prior art search and a freedom to operate assessment: the first tells you whether you can obtain a patent. The second tells you whether you can sell the product without infringing somebody else's.
- Filing: a provisional specification secures a priority date and buys 12 months in which to file the complete specification. A complete specification must fully and particularly describe the invention, disclose the best method known to the applicant, and end with claims defining the scope of protection.
- Publication: the application is published after 18 months from the priority date under Section 11A, or earlier on a request for early publication. Rights are notional until grant, but publication starts the clock for third parties.
- Request for examination: under the Patents (Amendment) Rules, 2024, notified on 15/03/2024, the period for filing the request is 31 months from the priority date or the date of filing, whichever is earlier, for applications filed on or after that date. For earlier applications the period remains 48 months.
- First Examination Report: response, and hearing where required.
- Pre-grant opposition: under Section 25(1), which any person may file after publication and before grant; the Controller now considers whether a prima facie case is made out.
- Grant: followed by post-grant opposition under Section 25(2), available to a person interested within one year from the date of publication of grant, and revocation under Section 64, whether by petition or by counterclaim in an infringement suit.
5.4 Filing abroad, and a provision that is regularly missed
There is no world patent. The Patent Cooperation Treaty, in force for India since 07/12/1998, provides a single international application, an international search report and a written opinion, and time. It defers the expensive decision, since national phase entry in India is at 31 months from the priority date. It does not grant anything. Grant remains a matter for each national office.
Section 39 deserves separate mention because it is regularly overlooked in cross-border research collaborations. A person resident in India may not, without the written permission of the Controller, apply outside India for a patent for an invention unless an application for a patent for the same invention has been made in India not less than six weeks earlier, and no secrecy direction is in force in respect of it. Anyone doing research in India for a foreign parent, or filing first in the United States as a matter of habit, should check this provision before filing, not after.
5.5 Keeping the patent
Renewal fees are payable from the third year and must be paid to keep the patent in force. Separately, Section 146(2) requires a statement as to the working of the patented invention in India. Under Rule 131 as amended in 2024, the statement on Form 27 is now furnished once in respect of every period of three financial years, within six months of the expiry of each such period, and the form no longer requires disclosure of revenue or value.
5.6 Compulsory licences, government use and essential medicines
The exclusivity is not unqualified. The Patents Act contains a set of balancing provisions, of which the following are the most important:
- Section 84: at any time after the expiration of three years from the grant, any interested person may apply for a compulsory licence on any of three grounds, namely that the reasonable requirements of the public with respect to the patented invention have not been satisfied, that the patented invention is not available to the public at a reasonably affordable price, or that the patented invention is not worked in the territory of India.
- Section 92: compulsory licences on notification by the Central Government in circumstances of national emergency, extreme urgency or public non-commercial use.
- Section 92A: compulsory licence for the export of patented pharmaceutical products to countries with insufficient or no manufacturing capacity, giving effect to the Doha Declaration on the TRIPS Agreement and Public Health.
- Section 100: use of an invention for the purposes of government, and Section 47, which imports conditions into every grant, including use by government and use for the purpose of experiment or research.
- Section 107A(b): permits acts done for the purpose of development and submission of information required under law, the provision commonly called the Bolar exemption, and which is what allows generic manufacturers to prepare regulatory filings before patent expiry.
In Bayer Corporation v. Union of India, decided by the Bombay High Court on 15/07/2014, the court upheld India's first compulsory licence, granted under Section 84 in respect of a patented anti-cancer drug, and the Special Leave Petition against that decision was dismissed by the Supreme Court in December 2014. The pricing of the patented drug, the extent to which the reasonable requirements of the public were met, and the meaning of working in the territory of India were all in issue.
For medicines, devices and instruments the patent is only part of the answer. The sensible structure is layered: a patent for the invention, a design registration for the appearance, a trade mark for the brand, copyright for the manuals and embedded software, and trade secret protection for the process parameters that never appear in the specification. Regulatory approvals sit alongside and are governed separately.
VI. Standard essential patents and FRAND terms
A standard essential patent is a patent that cannot be avoided by a manufacturer who wishes to comply with a technical standard, whether in telecommunications, video coding, connectivity or increasingly in automotive and connected devices. Because the standard removes the alternatives, the patent holder acquires a structural power that ordinary patents do not confer.
The balancing mechanism is contractual rather than statutory. Standard setting organisations require members whose technology is included in a standard to undertake to license it on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms, universally abbreviated to FRAND. The undertaking is given to the standard setting organisation, and implementers claim the benefit of it. The Patents Act contains no separate code for such patents, so the disputes are resolved as ordinary infringement suits informed by the FRAND undertaking.
Indian jurisprudence has developed principally in the Delhi High Court. In Intex Technologies (India) Ltd v. Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson, decided by a Division Bench on 29/03/2023, the court considered prima facie essentiality, the presumption of validity, the conduct of the parties in negotiation and the payment of royalty during the pendency of the suit. In Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson v. Lava International Ltd., decided on 28/03/2024 after a full trial with expert evidence, the court held seven of the eight asserted patents valid and infringed and decreed damages computed on the royalty that would have been payable had a licence been taken on FRAND terms. That decision has been carried in appeal.
Several practical points emerge for both sides of such a negotiation:
- Negotiate in good faith and paper the negotiation: silence, delay and repeated requests for further information are read as holdout, and holdout is expensive.
- Claim charts matter: an implementer who does not answer a claim mapping is unlikely to be heard on essentiality later.
- Portfolio licensing: is the commercial norm, and Indian courts have not insisted on patent by patent licensing where the portfolio approach is shown to be workable and non-discriminatory.
- Comparable licences: are the usual evidence of a FRAND rate, and confidentiality clubs are the usual mechanism by which they are placed before the court.
- Interim security is a real risk: courts have required deposits or pro tem payments long before trial.
- Competition law arguments: run in parallel, and the relationship between the Patents Act and the Competition Act, 2002 in this field has itself been litigated. Anyone advising on the point should check the current position before relying on it.
VII. Know-how, trade secrets and technology transfer
7.1 The legal position
Know-how is the most widely relied upon and least legislated form of intellectual property in India. There is no dedicated trade secrets statute. Protection is assembled from contract, the equitable duty of confidence, the law of tort, and, where dishonesty is involved, the general criminal law.
Two limits are worth stating plainly. First, Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 makes every agreement in restraint of trade void to that extent, which is why post-employment non-compete covenants are difficult to enforce in India. Obligations of confidentiality are treated differently, because they restrain the use of particular information rather than the exercise of a trade. Second, a trade secret protects only what is in fact secret. Once the information is public, whether through the patent specification, a product launch or a careless disclosure, the protection is gone and cannot be recovered.
The Law Commission of India, in Report No. 289 on Trade Secrets and Economic Espionage dated 05/03/2024, recommended a standalone statute and annexed a draft Protection of Trade Secrets Bill, 2024, with carve-outs for whistleblowers, compulsory licensing, government use and the public interest. It has not been enacted. Until it is, the contract remains the principal instrument.
This also frames the strategic choice at the outset. A patent buys 20 years of exclusivity at the price of complete disclosure. A trade secret can last indefinitely but confers no right against independent discovery or reverse engineering. Process improvements, formulations that cannot be reverse engineered from the product, and manufacturing parameters are often better kept secret. Products that can be examined and copied are usually better patented.
7.2 Practical protection of know-how
- Identify and mark what is confidential: a blanket claim that everything is secret is treated as a claim that nothing is.
- Restrict access: on a need to know basis, with technical controls and access logs.
- Sign the non-disclosure agreement: before disclosure, not after the meeting at which the disclosure was made.
- Use employment agreements: that cover confidentiality, assignment of intellectual property created during employment, and, where lawful and reasonable, notice and garden leave.
- Run a written exit protocol: device return, access revocation, and a signed acknowledgement of continuing obligations.
- Flow the same obligations down: to vendors, contract manufacturers and consultants, and back to back with the customer obligations they support.
- Consider source code escrow: where a customer needs continuity of supply.
7.3 Transferring technology: the terms that decide the value
Whether the subject is a patent, know-how or both, the following are the terms that determine whether a technology transfer is worth what it appears to be worth:
- Definition of the licensed technology: and the documentation to be handed over. Vagueness here defeats everything that follows.
- Scope: field of use, territory, and whether the licence is exclusive, sole or non-exclusive.
- Sub-licensing: whether the licensee may sub-license, and whether it may appoint contract manufacturers.
- Consideration: lump sum, running royalty, the royalty base on which the rate applies, minimum guaranteed payments and milestones. The base is often more important than the rate.
- Improvements: who owns improvements made by the licensee, and whether grant-back to the licensor is exclusive or non-exclusive. Exclusive grant-back clauses attract competition scrutiny.
- Training: technical assistance, the transfer plan and acceptance testing.
- Quality control: which for a trade mark licence is not optional if the mark is to survive.
- Audit rights: reporting formats and the frequency of statements.
- Confidentiality: that survives termination, with a defined survival period.
- Warranties: on ownership and non-infringement, and the indemnity that backs them.
- Term and termination: and what happens on termination to stock, to work in progress and to the technology itself.
- Taxes and withholding: remittances are governed by the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 and the exchange control position in force, which should be confirmed before the commercial terms are fixed.
- Governing law: seat of arbitration, and the right to approach a court for urgent interim relief.
Where the technology is a standard essential patent, add the FRAND undertaking itself, the treatment of past sales, the comparable licences relied upon, and the mechanism for determining the rate if the parties cannot agree.
VIII. A short checklist
- Search before you adopt a name, not after the signage is printed.
- File across the classes the business actually operates in, and draft the specification of goods and services.
- Keep dated evidence of first use from the first day of use.
- Diarise renewals for marks and annuities for patents, and diarise them twice.
- Put a watch on the Journal and oppose within the four month window.
- File in India before filing abroad, or obtain permission under Section 39.
- Register the mark in every country where you sell or manufacture, and consider Madrid where the list is long.
- Decide consciously between patent and trade secret for each piece of technology, and record the decision.
- Get confidentiality and assignment clauses into every employment, vendor and consultancy agreement.
- Record marks and patents with Customs if counterfeit imports are a risk.
- Audit the portfolio annually: what is registered, what is used, what has lapsed, and what is now being sold that nothing covers.
- Enforce early and consistently. Rights that are policed are rights that survive.
A trade secret protects only what is in fact secret. Once the information is public, the protection is gone and cannot be recovered.
Two-minute explainers on the questions these essays raise.
The Office publishes short video versions of its long-form writing. Subscribe to be notified when the explainer for this article is released.
Sources and provisions referred to
Statutes and rules
- Trade Marks Act, 1999: Sections 2(1)(e), 2(1)(g), 2(1)(m), 2(1)(zb), 2(1)(zg), 9 (including the proviso to 9(1) and 9(3)), 11 (including 11(6) to 11(9)), 14, 15, 17, 21, 23, 25, 27(2), 28, 29, 31, 33, 34, 35, 47, 57, 134, 135 and 154; Chapters VIII and XII
- Trade Marks Rules, 2017: Rule 124 and the Fourth Schedule
- Patents Act, 1970: Sections 2(1)(ja), 3 (including 3(d), 3(i) and 3(k)), 4, 11A, 25(1), 25(2), 39, 47, 53, 64, 84, 92, 92A, 100, 107A(b) and 146(2)
- Patents Rules, 2003, as amended: Rule 131 and Form 27; Patents (Amendment) Rules, 2024, notified on 15/03/2024
- Copyright Act, 1957
- Designs Act, 2000
- Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999
- Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmers' Rights Act, 2001
- Semiconductor Integrated Circuits Layout-Design Act, 2000
- Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act, 1950
- Commercial Courts Act, 2015
- Delhi High Court Intellectual Property Rights Division Rules, 2022
- Tribunals Reforms Act, 2021
- Intellectual Property Rights (Imported Goods) Enforcement Rules, 2007
- Competition Act, 2002
- Indian Contract Act, 1872: Section 27
- Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999
- Protection of Trade Secrets Bill, 2024 (draft annexed to Law Commission Report No. 289)
Treaties and conventions
- Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property: Article 6bis
- Convention establishing the World Intellectual Property Organization; Berne Convention; Patent Cooperation Treaty; Budapest Treaty; Marrakesh Treaty; WIPO Copyright Treaty and WPPT
- TRIPS Agreement and the Doha Declaration on the TRIPS Agreement and Public Health
- NICE Classification of goods and services
- Rome Convention, Singapore Treaty on the Law of Trademarks, Patent Law Treaty and UPOV Convention (India not a party)
Cases
- Novartis AG v. Union of India, decided on 01/04/2013
- Bayer Corporation v. Union of India, Bombay High Court, 15/07/2014; Special Leave Petition dismissed by the Supreme Court, December 2014
- Toyota Jidosha Kabushiki Kaisha v. Prius Auto Industries Ltd., decided on 14/12/2017
- Intex Technologies (India) Ltd v. Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson, Delhi High Court, Division Bench, 29/03/2023
- Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson v. Lava International Ltd., decided on 28/03/2024
Official documents
- Law Commission of India, Report No. 289 on Trade Secrets and Economic Espionage, dated 05/03/2024
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to register a trade mark to have rights in it?
No. Section 27(2) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 preserves the common law action for passing off, so an unregistered mark can still be defended by proving goodwill in India, a misrepresentation by the defendant and damage. What you do not get without registration is an infringement action, the exclusive right conferred by Section 28 and the presumption of validity under Section 31. Registration is also far cheaper to enforce than goodwill, which has to be proved case by case. Keep dated evidence of first use either way, because Section 34 protects a prior user against a later registrant.
How long does a patent last in India, and what keeps it alive?
Twenty years from the date of filing, under Section 53 of the Patents Act, 1970. The term is not extendable. Two things keep it alive. Renewal fees are payable from the third year, and a statement as to the working of the invention in India is required by Section 146(2). Under Rule 131 as amended in 2024, that statement on Form 27 is furnished once for every period of three financial years, within six months of the expiry of each such period, and no longer asks for revenue figures. Miss the renewals and the patent ceases, whatever its commercial value.
Is a non-disclosure agreement enforceable in India?
Yes. An obligation of confidence is enforceable by contract and in equity, even though India has no dedicated trade secrets statute. The distinction to hold on to is that Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 makes agreements in restraint of trade void, which is why post-employment non-compete covenants are difficult to enforce, while confidentiality obligations restrain the use of particular information rather than the exercise of a trade and are treated differently. Sign the agreement before the disclosure rather than after it, identify what is confidential, and remember that once the information is public the protection is gone.
Does an Indian trade mark protect me abroad?
No. Intellectual property rights are territorial, so an Indian registration is an Indian right and is not automatically honoured anywhere else. Protection has to be sought wherever the business sells, wherever it manufactures and wherever counterfeits of its goods are made. Two routes exist. The first is direct national filing in each country, using convention priority within six months of the Indian application. The second is the Madrid Protocol, to which India has been a party since 08/07/2013, which gives one application, one fee stream and one renewal date but no single right, because each designated office applies its own law.
Who owns the intellectual property created by an employee or a contractor?
It depends on the contract, which is why the clause matters more than the job title. An employment agreement should expressly assign intellectual property created during the employment. Under the Copyright Act, 1957 a work made in the course of employment under a contract of service generally vests in the employer in the absence of an agreement to the contrary, but patents and know-how have no equivalent default rule. A contractor or consultant is not an employee, and nothing passes automatically. Put confidentiality and written assignment clauses into every employment, vendor and consultancy agreement before the work begins.
These answers are educational summaries of the article above; they are not legal advice on any individual matter.
Corrections: if you find an error of law or fact in this article, write to contact@lokeshbhardwajlawoffices.com with the subject 'Correction'. Corrections are made in the text and noted here with the date.
This article is published for general information and public legal education only. It does not constitute legal advice and does not create an advocate-client relationship. Every intellectual property matter turns on its own facts and documents, and the law stated is as on the date of publication and is liable to change. Readers should obtain advice specific to their own facts before acting. Published in compliance with the Bar Council of India Rules, Chapter II, Part VI, Rule 36. No part of this article is intended to solicit professional engagement.
← Articles